Your Retirement Investments Are Probably Fueling Climate Change
Digest
This podcast delves into the intersection of climate change and retirement savings, focusing on the role of major asset managers like Vanguard. The host examines how Vanguard's investments in fossil fuels, including "carbon bombs," could exacerbate climate change and jeopardize the financial security of its clients. The podcast explores the arguments for and against ESG investing, highlighting the challenges of aligning investments with personal values and the need for greater transparency in the financial sector. It also discusses the efforts of activists to pressure Vanguard to shift its investments away from fossil fuels and towards clean, renewable energy, including protests, shareholder resolutions, and letter-writing campaigns. The podcast examines the potential financial risks associated with fossil fuel investments, highlighting research that suggests the sector has underperformed the market over the past decade and faces increasing financial risks due to climate change. It also introduces climate-friendly investment firms like Sphere, which aim to provide investors with fossil-free options and challenge the dominance of traditional asset managers. The podcast concludes by discussing the shift from an extractive economy to a regenerative economy, emphasizing the importance of investment choices in shaping a sustainable future.
Outlines
Climate Change and Retirement Savings
This chapter explores the connection between climate change and retirement savings, focusing on how major asset managers like Vanguard are investing billions in fossil fuel projects, potentially jeopardizing the future of the planet and the financial security of their clients.
The Game of Life and Climate Change
The host reflects on the game of life and how climate change impacts his own retirement plans, highlighting the potential consequences of rising sea levels, extreme weather, and the global economy.
Carbon Bombs and Investment Decisions
This chapter delves into the concept of "carbon bombs," massive fossil fuel projects that could release significant amounts of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, and how major asset managers like Vanguard are investing in these projects.
Vanguard's Investment Strategy and Climate Concerns
This chapter examines Vanguard's investment strategy, focusing on its index funds and its stance on climate change. Critics argue that Vanguard's investments in fossil fuels are not in the best long-term interests of the planet or its clients, while Vanguard maintains that its strategy is designed to maximize returns for its clients.
The Lorax and the Future of Investing
This chapter draws a parallel between the story of The Lorax and the current state of investing, highlighting the potential consequences of prioritizing short-term profits over environmental sustainability.
The SOS Vanguard Campaign
This chapter introduces the SOS Vanguard campaign, a movement aimed at pressuring Vanguard to shift its investments away from fossil fuel projects towards clean, renewable energy.
Vanguard's Climate Actions and Backlash
This chapter examines Vanguard's recent actions on climate change, including its participation in the Net Zero Asset Managers Initiative and its vote to replace Exxon board members. It also explores the political backlash from conservative lawmakers and the fossil fuel industry.
Confronting Vanguard and Its Investors
This chapter explores the various strategies employed by activists to confront Vanguard and its investors, including letter-writing campaigns, shareholder resolutions, and protests.
Keywords
Carbon Bombs
Large-scale fossil fuel projects that could release significant amounts of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, potentially exacerbating climate change and jeopardizing global climate goals.
ESG Investing
Environmental, social, and governance investing, a type of sustainable investing that considers environmental, social, and governance factors in investment decisions.
Fossil Free Funds
A free online tool that helps investors understand the fossil fuel exposure of their portfolios and make informed decisions about their investments.
Regenerative Economy
An economic model that focuses on restoring and regenerating natural systems, promoting sustainable practices, and creating a more equitable and just society.
Divestment Campaign
A strategy used to pressure companies or institutions to change their practices by withdrawing investments from them.
Fiduciary Duty
A legal obligation to act in the best interests of another party, such as a client or beneficiary.
Eminent Domain
The power of the government to take private property for public use, even if the owner does not want to sell it.
Net Zero Asset Managers Initiative
A global initiative aimed at aligning all investments to reach net zero carbon emissions by 2050 or sooner.
Q&A
How are major asset managers like Vanguard contributing to the climate crisis?
Vanguard and other large asset managers are investing billions of dollars in fossil fuel projects, including "carbon bombs" that could release significant amounts of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, potentially exacerbating climate change.
What are the arguments for and against ESG investing?
Supporters of ESG investing argue that it aligns investments with ethical and sustainable values, while critics contend that it often amounts to greenwashing and does little to address climate change effectively.
How can individual investors make their portfolios more climate-friendly?
Investors can use tools like Fossil Free Funds to understand the fossil fuel exposure of their portfolios and choose climate-friendly investment options. They can also engage with asset managers like Vanguard to advocate for more sustainable investment practices.
What are the potential financial risks associated with fossil fuel investments?
Research suggests that the fossil fuel industry has underperformed the market over the past decade and faces increasing financial risks due to climate change, shifting energy markets, and the transition to cleaner energy.
What is the regenerative economy, and how does it differ from the extractive economy?
The regenerative economy focuses on restoring and regenerating natural systems, promoting sustainable practices, and creating a more equitable and just society, while the extractive economy relies on extracting resources from the earth and exploiting labor.
How can we encourage a shift towards a more sustainable and just financial system?
By raising awareness about the environmental and social impacts of investments, supporting climate-friendly investment firms, and advocating for policy changes that promote sustainable finance, we can encourage a shift towards a more sustainable and just financial system.
Show Notes
Reveal reporter Jonathan Jones was working on a story about a massive coal plant expansion in Montana when he wondered who was bankrolling the project. It turns out a major shareholder of the energy company driving the project was The Vanguard Group, the investment firm where he happens to have his retirement savings.
This discovery put Jones on a quest to find out why Vanguard and other asset managers continue to invest in fossil fuels at a time when we need to burn less oil, gas, and coal.
This week on Reveal, we look at the unsettling truth that our retirement savings could be fueling the very climate crisis that threatens our planet. From the site of a massive natural gas pipeline cutting through Appalachia to the boardrooms of Vanguard, we explore how our investments might be working against our values—and what can be done to align them with a sustainable future.
- Support Reveal’s journalism at Revealnews.org/donatenow
- Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to get the scoop on new episodes at Revealnews.org/newsletter
- Connect with us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram
Table of contents
United States
