The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – October 2025
Dive into the captivating world of True Crime with us! This blog unpacks gripping stories from recent podcast episodes, featuring the chilling case of Chung Yoo Jung’s obsession, the notorious Murdoch family saga, the unsolved murders of Destiny Jackson and Nazira Mohamed, and the perplexing death of Ellen Greenberg. We’ll also explore the mysterious disappearance of Trevelyne Evans, the tragic murder of Jessica Starr, the 23-year cold case of Leslie Priar, the complex conspiracy behind Cliff Lambert’s murder, the trials of Eric Thompson for John Togahara’s death, and a roundup of other compelling true crime cases. Tune in for in-depth analysis and to uncover the truth behind these captivating narratives.
The 10 Best True Crime episodes
A Deadly Obsession with True Crime in Korea
True crime’s dark allure fuels obsession and real-world tragedy, amplified by social media’s unchecked speculation.
This podcast delves into the disturbing intersection of true crime consumption and real-life violence, exemplified by the case of Chung Yoo Jung, a young South Korean woman whose obsession with true crime led her to commit a brutal murder. The episode explores the societal factors contributing to her isolation and fixation, including high youth unemployment and the pervasive influence of media. It also examines the phenomenon of “social media sleuths” and their detrimental impact, as illustrated by Craig Wainwright’s experience of being wrongly accused online after his wife’s death. The podcast questions the ethical boundaries of true crime as entertainment, highlighting the potential for exploitation and the lasting trauma inflicted on victims and their families, ultimately advocating for truth over sensationalism.
INFAMOUS: The Murdaugh Family Murders
The Murdoch family saga unfolds, revealing a powerful dynasty, a double murder, financial crimes, and a web of suspicious deaths, culminating in Alec Murdoch’s conviction.
This podcast delves into the shocking Murdoch family saga, beginning with the double murder of Margaret (Maggie) and Paul Murdoch. It explores the powerful and influential Murdoch dynasty in South Carolina, their century-long reign of power, and the suspicious circumstances surrounding multiple deaths connected to the family, including Gloria Satterfield and Steven Smith. The narrative highlights Alec Murdoch’s alleged financial crimes, his staged suicide attempt, and his eventual trial and conviction for the murders of his wife and son. The defense’s arguments, focusing on circumstantial evidence and reasonable doubt, are contrasted with the prosecution’s theory of motive rooted in financial ruin and image protection. The episode also touches upon the Mallory Beach boat crash, the ongoing investigations into unresolved deaths, and the lingering questions about the family’s legacy and the true extent of their influence.
MURDERED: Destiny Jackson & Nazirah Muhammad
This podcast episode details the investigation into the murders of Destiny Jackson and Nazira Mohamed, highlighting evidence, suspects, and a public appeal for justice.
This episode of “Dark Down East” delves into the tragic murders of Destiny Jackson and Nazira Mohamed in Indiana. The investigation began with the discovery of their bodies in their apartment, revealing signs of a struggle and initial evidence like bullet casings and a shoe print. Investigators meticulously collected forensic evidence, including DNA from blue gloves, and established a timeline through phone records and interviews. Theories about the motive ranged from drug disputes to personal vendettas, with Nazira’s ex-girlfriend’s brother and a local marijuana dealer named “Chip” emerging as persons of interest. Despite advanced DNA testing, the perpetrator(s) remain unidentified, leading to a public appeal for any information that could bring closure to the victims’ families. The episode also features promotional segments for various products and services.
UPDATE: Ellen Greenberg
The Ellen Greenberg case details a teacher’s death, initially ruled suicide, but later re-examined as homicide due to conflicting evidence and expert opinions.
This episode delves into the complex and tragic case of Ellen Greenberg, a 27-year-old first-grade teacher whose death was initially ruled a suicide. The narrative meticulously details the discovery of her body, the initial crime scene investigation, and the medical examiner’s early findings. However, as the autopsy progressed, significant discrepancies emerged, revealing numerous stab wounds inconsistent with self-infliction, bruises indicating past abuse, and a ruling of homicide. The investigation was further complicated by a compromised crime scene, the removal of personal belongings, and conflicting witness statements. The podcast highlights the persistent efforts of Ellen’s parents to uncover the truth, their engagement with forensic experts, and their legal battles against the medical examiner’s office. Despite numerous roadblocks and the changing manner of death from homicide to suicide and back, the Greenbergs remain steadfast in their belief that Ellen was a victim of domestic violence and a brutal homicide. The episode concludes with the case proceeding to trial, emphasizing the ongoing search for justice.
MISSING: Trevaline Evans
This podcast delves into the 35-year-old unsolved disappearance of Trevelyne Evans, exploring amateur investigations, potential burial sites, and serial killer theories.
This episode of “So Supernatural” investigates the perplexing 1990 disappearance of Trevelyne Evans in North Wales. Initially treated as a missing person case, evidence at her shop suggested foul play. Amateur investigators, the Sutton brothers, discovered potential human remains beneath a trapdoor at a golf club, reigniting the case. Theories explored include involvement of her husband, Richard Evans, a mysterious man seen with her, and the possibility of her being a victim of serial killers Robin Ligas or Christopher Halliwell. The appearance of cryptic memorial plaques in Rudlin adds another layer of mystery, hinting at a possible cover-up or an anonymous plea for justice. The case remains unsolved, with lingering questions about the investigation and the community’s silence.
MURDERED: Jessica Starr
This podcast investigates the unsolved murder of Jessica Starr, highlighting alleged police mishandling and exploring potential suspects and motives.
This episode delves into the unsolved murder of Jessica Starr, a young woman killed in Elkhart, Indiana. Ashley Flowers introduces the case, emphasizing the importance of giving victims a voice and highlighting Kylie Lowe’s podcast, Dark Down East. The podcast details the night of the attack, witness accounts, and the initial police investigation, which the family believes was mishandled. Suspects, including Jessica’s ex-boyfriend Tavares “Bae” Browning and Josh, are discussed, along with theories involving a former roommate, Anna, and potential connections to Jessica’s work with domestic violence victims. The family’s frustration with the Elkhart Police Department’s perceived lack of progress and communication is a recurring theme. Jessica’s father dedicated himself to the investigation, and the family aims to honor her legacy by supporting Safe Haven, a local women’s shelter.
A Perfect Spring Morning
A decades-long investigation into Leslie Priar’s murder is finally solved using advanced DNA genealogy, leading to the arrest of her daughter’s ex-boyfriend.
This podcast chronicles the complex and lengthy investigation into the murder of Leslie Priar, a Chevy Chase resident found dead on May 2, 2001. Initially, suspicion fell on her husband, Sandy Priar, and her boss, Brett Reedy, due to inconsistencies and suspicious behavior. However, after years of stalled progress, advancements in DNA technology and forensic genealogy provided the breakthrough needed. By analyzing unknown DNA found at the crime scene, investigators identified Eugene Gligor, the ex-boyfriend of Leslie’s daughter, Lauren. Gligor, who had a history of break-ins and assault, was eventually linked to the murder. The investigation revealed a possible escape route and a plan to obtain his DNA. After 23 years, Gligor was arrested, confessed to second-degree murder, and received a 22-year sentence, bringing a measure of closure to Leslie Priar’s family.
The Prince, The Whiz Kid & The Millionaire
A complex Dateline investigation unravels the murder of wealthy art collector Cliff Lambert, exposing a web of deceit, con artists, and a shocking conspiracy.
This Dateline episode chronicles the intricate investigation into the disappearance and murder of Cliff Lambert, a wealthy art collector from Palm Springs. The case began with his friend Eddie Mulligan reporting him missing, revealing signs of disturbance at his home. As detectives delved deeper, they uncovered a complex conspiracy involving multiple suspects, including Danny Garcia, Cliff’s online date, and Cachal Narula, a con artist posing as a prince. The investigation was fraught with challenges, including a lack of forensic evidence and the defendants’ attempts to manipulate the legal system. Crucial evidence emerged from text messages on Danny Garcia’s iPhone, detailing “Operation CL,” a plan to defraud and murder Cliff. Despite initial convictions being overturned due to illegal recordings, the discovery of Cliff’s remains eventually led to the conviction of Danny Garcia, Miguel Bustamante, and David Replogel for first-degree murder. The case also revealed that Cliff Lambert himself had engaged in deception, potentially contributing to his downfall. The narrative highlights the perseverance of law enforcement and the enduring impact of true crime on justice.
The Bucket Hat Mystery
Dateline investigates the murder of John Togahara, leading to the arrest and trials of Eric Thompson, marked by questionable evidence and mistrials, ultimately resulting in a guilty verdict.
This Dateline episode chronicles the murder of John Togahara, a Hawaiian acupuncturist, and the subsequent investigation and trials of Eric Thompson. The investigation initially focused on a white pickup truck and a bucket hat found near the crime scene. DNA evidence from the hat, though later questioned due to crime lab deficiencies, led to Thompson’s arrest. Two trials resulted in mistrials due to hung juries, with the defense arguing flawed police work and unreliable DNA evidence. In the third trial, Eric Thompson was found guilty of second-degree murder. The episode also touches upon Ondec’s small business line of credit and promotes Dateline’s podcast.
An amusement park murder. An aspiring beauty queen’s murder. Plus, a detective’s documentary.
This podcast covers celebrity memoirs, NFL news, and various true crime cases, including murder investigations and cold case resolutions.
This podcast features an introduction to Jenna Bush Hager’s “Open Book” podcast with actor Jay Ellis, a promotional segment for “The Today Show” focusing on NFL content, and “Dateline True Crime Weekly.” The true crime segments highlight a Philadelphia case involving the death of Cata Scott, the investigation into Doris Whirl’s murder in Coffey County, and updates on the Dan Sarafini, Paul Zumat, and Nicholas Rossi cases. Additionally, the podcast discusses the use of investigative genetic genealogy and documentaries to solve cold cases, including the Grand River baby case in Ontario.
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – August 2025
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – September 2025
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – April 2025