DiscoverSeason of the Cosy Witch(Not So) Practical Magic
(Not So) Practical Magic

(Not So) Practical Magic

Update: 2026-10-02
Share

Description

In this episode of Season of the Cosy Witch, we’re chatting about the sequel to the classic witchy sister film, Practical Magic. We’re big fans of the original film, and we have quite a lot of thoughts and feelings about Practical Magic 2. We promise we did really enjoy the film, but that didn’t stop us from having a frank discussion about the sequel’s (many) foibles 

So grab your cup of (self-stirring) tea and your black umbrella, and let’s get into it!

In This Episode we…

  • Critique the film’s move away from ‘practical magic’ to ‘Marvel-style’ magic

  • Spend way too much time hating on custard

  • Discuss the romance and the bewildering role of Lee Pace

  • Question the egregious product placements

  • Argue how the film centres men and heteronormativity 

Episode Reading List 

We're twin sisters who love cosy books and since we're always talking about them with each other, we thought we'd share those conversations with other likeminded readers who want to understand why they love these kinds of stories, what they can teach us about our real world, how they can be catalysts for change, and how they are shaping the landscape of publishing and reading. Angie Spoto is a fantasy novelist based in Edinburgh, Scotland. She’s currently working on her third novel, a cosy romantasy inspired by Scottish folklore. Sarah Spoto is a podcaster and entrepreneur living in New England in the USA.

If this sounds like your cup of tea, join us every month for a new cosy conversation. 

This episode was edited by Lila Woodbridge.

Season of the Cosy Witch has a Substack! Join us for deep-dives into the cosy genre, tropes, our favourite cosy books and fascinating topics.

Instagram: @seasonofthecosywitch

cosy fantasy, cozy fantasy, cozy sci-fi, cozy fantasy books, what is cozy fantasy, what is cozy fantasy, cozy fantasy tropes, cozy fantasy reading list, fantasy book podcast, book review podcast, Legends and Lattes, low stakes fantasy, found family fantasy, queernorm fantasy


Comments 
loading
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

(Not So) Practical Magic

(Not So) Practical Magic

Angie Spoto, Sarah Spoto