A lifelong Green Day fan sits down with a known Green Day hater to rate Dookie—and the results might surprise you. Also: Sam’s birthday cake and party hats, firecracker chaos, neighbour drama, another heated interlude argument and a discussion of the Pop-Punk Mount Rushmore and the perfect pop punk song. Oh—and Jayson might actually love Dookie now?

Next week’s album: Say It Like You Mean It by The Starting Line.

Get the rating guide at poppunkbookclub.com and rate along with us.