DiscoverThe Shaft Podcast#144. Are Rigid Philosophies KILLING Teams?
#144. Are Rigid Philosophies KILLING Teams?

#144. Are Rigid Philosophies KILLING Teams?

Update: 2025-09-02
Share

Description

Grimsby Town knocked Manchester United out on pens after a 2–2, but the real story is bigger. Are rigid systems hurting United more than opponents are? We break down the control issues, rest defense, the overload of No. 10s, why transitions look so easy against United, and what quick fixes could work without ripping up the entire philosophy.


What we cover:

- Why control vanished against Grimsby and Fulham

- Rest defense explained and why United retreat too deep

- The No. 10 overload at United: Bruno, Mount, Brian, Cunha, Amad

- Play your best in best roles or force the system

- Quick, low-risk tweaks for Burnley

- Philosophy vs results: evolve the details or die on the hill


Comment your take: keep the system and tweak, or change it fast?


#PremierLeague, #EPL, #ManchesterUnited, #ManUnited, #GrimsbyTown, #CarabaoCup, #FootballTactics, #Tactics, #RestDefense, #HighPress, #CounterPress, #BrunoFernandes, #MasonMount, #RubenAmorim, #FootballAnalysis, #SoccerAnalysis, #FootballPodcast, #SportsPodcast, #Coaching, #Transitions, #BuildUpPlay, #No10, #MidfieldBalance, #DefensiveShape, #PressingTriggers



Subscribe to our channels and enjoy this episode:

YouTube: / @theshaftpodcasts. .

Spotify: https://spotify.link/oHwF5hicHDb


Appreciations for this Episode:

Host: Andy Terku and Erasmus Segbefia

Video Production: Andrews Terkpertey

Video Editing: Samuel Okuadjo


Timestamps:

00:00 United’s struggles and the Grimsby shock

06:57 Roles, misfits, and mentality

19:01 No.10 overload and transfer missteps

21:43 Immediate fixes, defensive shape, keeper choice, adaptability and wrap up

28:56 Philosophy vs. Pragmatism in Football Management

Comments 
In Channel
loading
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

#144. Are Rigid Philosophies KILLING Teams?

#144. Are Rigid Philosophies KILLING Teams?

The Shaft Podcast