Listen Top Shows Blog

#287 Sinister Sister

#287 Sinister Sister

Update: 2025-09-04

1

Share

Description

Claire Miller was just 14 years old when she murdered her older sister (just 19) who suffered from cerebral palsy, while she slept! Claire, was a rising TikTok star who may have suffered a mental break that led to her killing her sister, or she could have been obsessed with violence all along.

Check out our other shows!:

Cryptic Soup w/ Thena & Kylee

Strange & Unexplained

True Crime Guys YouTube

EVERYTHING TRUE CRIME GUYS: https://linktr.ee/Truecrimeguysproductions

True Crime Guys Music: True Crime Guys Music on Spotify

Code: Crimepine

Patreon.com/truecrimeguys

Patreon.com/sandupodcast

Merch: truecrimeguys.threadless.com

Sources:

https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/claire-miller-pleads-guilty-but-mentally-ill-in-sisters-stabbing-death-update/article_b7e3f45e-bea4-11ed-ae5f-ff4dc9d21719.html

https://www.fox43.com/article/news/crime/claire-miller-sentencing-guilty-plea-homicide-helen-miller/521-51fa4e94-3892-4ab7-9764-b15faf68ae11

https://allthatsinteresting.com/claire-miller

https://dailyvoice.com/pennsylvania/lancaster/news/pa-tiktoker-who-admitted-to-killing-her-wheelchair-bound-sister-learns-her-fate-da/858650/

https://nypost.com/2022/07/01/pennsylvania-girl-claire-miller-wouldve-killed-sooner-if-it-meant-mcdonalds-breakfast/

Comments

In Channel

#287 Sinister Sister

#287 Sinister Sister

2025-09-0436:32

Surgery PTSD, Denmark's Unwanted Pet Solution, Air Brushed Henry Rollins and the most French crime ever: Headlines 31

Surgery PTSD, Denmark's Unwanted Pet Solution, Air Brushed Henry Rollins and the most French crime ever: Headlines 31

2025-08-2841:39

#286 Daddy's Favorite

#286 Daddy's Favorite

2025-08-2142:07

#285 With Friends Like These

#285 With Friends Like These

2025-08-1435:43

#284 Baby DeOrr

#284 Baby DeOrr

2025-08-0701:13:12

Nintendo Drama, Chuck E Cheese Arrested, A Final Destination Death, and Chicken Crime: Headlines 30

Nintendo Drama, Chuck E Cheese Arrested, A Final Destination Death, and Chicken Crime: Headlines 30

2025-07-3131:30

#283 The Worst Valentine's Day Ever

#283 The Worst Valentine's Day Ever

2025-07-2437:52

#282 Peepin' Steven

#282 Peepin' Steven

2025-07-1743:41

#281 Papa Lou & The Boys

#281 Papa Lou & The Boys

2025-07-1052:39

Happy Careers, Alligator Alcatraz, and The Idaho Sniper: Headlines 29

Happy Careers, Alligator Alcatraz, and The Idaho Sniper: Headlines 29

2025-07-0329:18

#280 Lying In Wait

#280 Lying In Wait

2025-06-2635:55

#279 American Animals

#279 American Animals

2025-06-1933:13

#278 The Adventures of Cocaine Bear & Andrew Carter Thornton II

#278 The Adventures of Cocaine Bear & Andrew Carter Thornton II

2025-06-1230:47

Killa Kangaroo, METH ARREST, CIA goof-up, METH ARREST, a clean poop, and uh...METH ARREST: Headlines 28

Killa Kangaroo, METH ARREST, CIA goof-up, METH ARREST, a clean poop, and uh...METH ARREST: Headlines 28

2025-06-0533:47

#277 Going Postal

#277 Going Postal

2025-05-2947:48

#276 Death At Wakefest

#276 Death At Wakefest

2025-05-1548:31

Introducing "Slaycation"

Introducing "Slaycation"

2025-05-1127:54

#275 The Murder of Lindsay Hawker

#275 The Murder of Lindsay Hawker

2025-05-0842:43

#274 There's a serial killer named Howard Allen?

#274 There's a serial killer named Howard Allen?

2025-05-0128:10

Weezer Wife, A Pissed Off Citizen, McDonalds 911, and The Real Tiger King: Headlines 27

Weezer Wife, A Pissed Off Citizen, McDonalds 911, and The Real Tiger King: Headlines 27

2025-04-2429:58

00:00

00:00

x

#287 Sinister Sister

#287 Sinister Sister

True Crime Guys