In this episode the hosts of Box Office Bucket List’s "Second Opinions" open with a riff about Bruce Campbell cameos and then dig into a long conversation about Charlie Bartlett. They summarize the plot and central themes: a troubled teen who helps others while avoiding his own pain, and how good intentions can cause real harm.

The panel analyzes the main characters—Charlie, Len, Kip/Bevins, and Principal Nathan (Robert Downey Jr.)—noting strong performances, especially Anton Yelchin, while arguing that some supporting players deserved more screen time. They debate whether Charlie’s actions are sympathetic or irresponsible and discuss the film’s tone, memorable scenes, and the controversial moments that land and those that don’t.

Hosts compare Charlie Bartlett to other teen films like The Breakfast Club, Rushmore, and Election, and suggest the story might have worked well as a limited TV series to explore sidelined characters. They also reference other movies mentioned in the episode for context and contrast.