DiscoverThe Post Game Podcast#82: James Grugan - Helping Athletes Turn Athletic Experience Into Career Success
#82: James Grugan - Helping Athletes Turn Athletic Experience Into Career Success

#82: James Grugan - Helping Athletes Turn Athletic Experience Into Career Success

Update: 2025-09-17
Share

Description

James Grugan is the founder of Five Star Hiring, a recruiting firm specializing in helping student-athletes and former athletes transition into successful careers.

After spending most of his career at JG Wentworth, James identified a gap in the recruitment space, specifically working with student-athletes and helping them translate skills learned from the field to the workforce.

What You'll Hear About:

  • Why James left corporate life to focus on recruiting student-athletes
  • Building a professional network that opens doors and how to leverage it
  • LinkedIn strategies that get recruiters' attention
  • How to identify and articulate transferable skills from sports
  • Positioning athletic experience as equivalent to internships
  • Why sales roles can be great careers for athletes
  • Resume essentials that separate you from 95% of applicants
  • The one-minute follow-up email only 3-5% of candidates send
  • Interview preparation tactics borrowed from elite athletic preparation
  • Creative outreach methods in the application process


Timestamps:

(0:00 ) - Introduction to James Grugan

(3:10 ) - Background at JG Wentworth and career transition

(4:30 ) - Discovering the student-athlete recruiting niche

(6:20 ) - Starting Five Star Hiring and early business strategies

(7:20 ) - "People want to help people"

(9:00 ) - LinkedIn strategy

(11:30 ) - Authentic follow-up techniques

(13:15 ) - The "Going Pro" presentation overview

(16:00 ) - Making skills transferable from sports

(18:30 ) - Performing under pressure and real-world application

(20:30 ) - Why sales is ideal for student-athletes

(23:00 ) - Resume essentials and common mistakes

(24:15 ) - Networking as the #1 strategy

(28:30 ) - Small actions that can lead to big advantages

(30:15 ) - Interview prep strategies

(36:50 ) -Universal job search principles

(38:15 ) - Current job market conditions and opportunities

(41:30 ) - Company partnerships and placement approach

(43:00 ) - Future plans for Five Star Hiring

(45:30 )- Specialized approach vs general career services

(46:15 ) - Contact information and where to find James


Links:

Email: jamesg@fivestarhiring.net

https://www.linkedin.com/in/james-grugan-713246169/

https://www.fivestarhiring.net/

Social Media: @fivestarhiring (YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, X)


The Post Game Podcast:

https://postgamepodcast.beehiiv.com/⁠

⁠https://www.instagram.com/thepostgame_podcast/

https://x.com/JoePod24⁠

https://www.linkedin.com/company/the-post-game-podcast/

Email me: joe.poduslenko@gmail.com

Comments 
In Channel
loading
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

#82: James Grugan - Helping Athletes Turn Athletic Experience Into Career Success

#82: James Grugan - Helping Athletes Turn Athletic Experience Into Career Success

Joe Poduslenko