Welcome back to Flop Stars!

This week, Billy and Greg take on the Queen of Pop herself, Madonna, as they determine once and for all if her 2003 album American Life really deserved all the hate. Oh honey, trust us when we tell you that it was an x-static process. (Get it?)

Elsewhere in the episode, we reveal which three pop stars make up their coven, try and name the three best Madonna songs ever (ahh!), and deliver their choices for Pop and Flop of the Week. Can anyone out there explain who, exactly, P!nk is making music for these days? Asking for a friend...

To listen to all the music talked about in this week's ep—or the good stuff, at least—be sure to check out the companion playlist on Apple Music and Spotify. Get into the groove!