Did Vikings Blow it by Passing on Aaron Rodgers for JJ McCarthy?

Update: 2025-07-07

Description

Minnesota Vikings fans are still debating if signing Aaron Rodgers was smarter than starting JJ McCarthy, so FanSided's Chris Schad and The Viking Age's Adam Patrick decided to break down the QB decision.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Comments

In Channel

JJ McCarthy’s Development Plan: Are the Vikings Handling It Right?

2025-10-1840:32

Minnesota Vikings 2025 Outlook: Tyler Forness Shares His Predictions

2025-10-1350:42

Vikings Head into Bye Week with Optimism About JJ McCarthy

2025-10-0753:33

Vikings Fans, Relax — Week 5 vs. Browns Could Spark Something Special

2025-10-0346:07

Vikings’ O-Line Injuries Complicating JJ McCarthy’s Return Timeline

2025-10-0146:46

Vikings Legend Jared Allen on QB Controversy, Kevin Williams, and More

2025-09-2830:24

Carson Wentz only needed 1 game to start a Vikings QB controversy

2025-09-2340:38

Vikings Season Now Rests On Carson Wentz (with Arif Hasan)

2025-09-1958:12

JJ McCarthy INJURED — The Big Question: When Will He Be Back?

2025-09-1646:32

JJ McCarthy Just Put the NFL on Notice With Insane Vikings Debut

2025-09-1251:37

Vikings (super) predictions for the 2025 season and MNF vs. the Bears

2025-09-0501:00:12

Adam Thielen is BACK with the Vikings! (with Jason Harmon)

2025-08-2956:59

What's next for the Vikings after trading Harrison Phillips? (with Lindsey Young)

2025-08-2441:23

JJ McCarthy wows Vikings fans in Patriots joint practices (with Thor Nystrom)

2025-08-1539:01

JJ McCarthy Smear Campaign and Vikings Solutions after Jordan Addison Suspension News

2025-08-1058:43

Is JJ McCarthy struggling or is the Vikings defense just REALLY good?

2025-08-0401:03:36

JJ McCarthy is better than Caleb Williams, plus early Vikings camp tidbits

2025-07-2651:05