DiscoverFirst Time ReadersDid the Fellowship Fail Boromir? (YES...and no)
Did the Fellowship Fail Boromir? (YES...and no)

Did the Fellowship Fail Boromir? (YES...and no)

Update: 2025-09-23
Share

Description

Did the fellowship fail Boromir? It’s a question someone asked in a comment a few videos ago and I haven’t been able to get it out of my head for the last few days. I think the answer is no…but also yes…absolutely yes.
Comments 
In Channel
The magical system of Middle Earth is Bizarre...

The magical system of Middle Earth is Bizarre...

2025-10-0410:11

JRR Tolkien is the best perspective shift writer I've ever read.

JRR Tolkien is the best perspective shift writer I've ever read.

2025-10-0310:36

This was the moment Pippin became a man...or a hobbit

This was the moment Pippin became a man...or a hobbit

2025-10-0210:02

Why the world needs more men like Éomer

Why the world needs more men like Éomer

2025-10-0120:35

Peter Jackson left out all the tension that JRR Tolkien built...

Peter Jackson left out all the tension that JRR Tolkien built...

2025-09-3017:23

This was the moment I fell in love with Aragorn

This was the moment I fell in love with Aragorn

2025-09-2918:48

The Beginning of the Two Towers is a MASTERCLASS in how to start a story

The Beginning of the Two Towers is a MASTERCLASS in how to start a story

2025-09-2814:40

Why you should read the Fellowship of the Ring

Why you should read the Fellowship of the Ring

2025-09-2717:13

Who is the greatest writer of all time?

Who is the greatest writer of all time?

2025-09-2616:44

Is the Fellowship of the Ring a better movie than book?

Is the Fellowship of the Ring a better movie than book?

2025-09-2532:56

Samwise Gamgee is EVEN BETTER in the Books

Samwise Gamgee is EVEN BETTER in the Books

2025-09-2416:00

Did the Fellowship Fail Boromir? (YES...and no)

Did the Fellowship Fail Boromir? (YES...and no)

2025-09-2325:18

How Aragorn being "erect" makes Tolkien an absolute MASTER of the English Language...

How Aragorn being "erect" makes Tolkien an absolute MASTER of the English Language...

2025-09-2209:28

Three WILD EVENTS that happened on the River in Fellowship of the Ring

Three WILD EVENTS that happened on the River in Fellowship of the Ring

2025-09-2114:23

I just want to talk about Galadriel giving Gimli three hairs from her golden head...

I just want to talk about Galadriel giving Gimli three hairs from her golden head...

2025-09-2014:12

The Gifts of Galadriel are SO INCREDIBLE in the Books...

The Gifts of Galadriel are SO INCREDIBLE in the Books...

2025-09-1915:48

This is the Reason why Tolkien "intensely disliked" Dune

This is the Reason why Tolkien "intensely disliked" Dune

2025-09-1815:29

The Mirror of Galadriel is so BIZARRE to me...

The Mirror of Galadriel is so BIZARRE to me...

2025-09-1720:41

What did Galadriel offer each member of the fellowship?

What did Galadriel offer each member of the fellowship?

2025-09-1614:10

This is the most BEAUTIFUL moment in the Fellowship of the Ring

This is the most BEAUTIFUL moment in the Fellowship of the Ring

2025-09-1509:34

loading
Google Play
Download from Google Play
Castbox
Download from App Store
usUnited States
00:00
00:00
1.0x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Did the Fellowship Fail Boromir? (YES...and no)

Did the Fellowship Fail Boromir? (YES...and no)

Jonathan Minnema