Did the Steelers make the wrong decision trading George Pickens to Dallas?

Update: 2025-11-18

Description

We held our thank you to the fans at our Fan Marconi thank you party Monday. George Pickens is second in the NFL in receiving yards and had a big game for Dallas. Should the Steelers have kept George Pickens? Joe is of two minds here. He doesn't think Pickens would have flourished in Pittsburgh, but the receiver room is poor and would have been worth the risk.

Comments

In Channel

The Pomp and Joe Show 11-18-2025

2025-11-1802:29:20

10AM - Did the Steelers make the wrong decision trading George Pickens to Dallas? Steelers fans weigh in on Pickens' success but problems in Pittsburgh

2025-11-1844:19

11AM - Nick Farabaugh thinks Aaron Rodgers will play against the Bears; Jeff Passan reports Pirates are in on Kyle Schwarber, wanted 1B Josh Naylor

2025-11-1831:39

12PM - The Mike Tomlin Press Conference 11-18-2025; Brian Batko joins, Mike Tomlin's thoughts on Chase spitting on Ramsey

2025-11-1846:35

1PM - Tomlin takes on Will Howard, Darnell Washington, and Mason Rudolph; Jeff Passan's report giving some Pirates fans hope for offseason spending

2025-11-1826:44

Jeff Passan's report giving some Pirates fans hope for offseason spending

2025-11-1810:28

Tomlin's takes on Will Howard, Darnell Washington, and Mason Rudolph

2025-11-1816:16

Brian Batko joins, Mike Tomlin's thoughts on Chase spitting on Ramsey

2025-11-1813:41

Jeff Passan reports Pirates are in on Kyle Schwarber, wanted 1B Josh Naylor

2025-11-1809:37

The Mike Tomlin Press Conference and our reaction 11-18-2025

2025-11-1832:53