DiscoverThe eat.simple PodcastDismantling diet dogma: Cookies, CPAPs, Critical Thinking & Context
Dismantling diet dogma: Cookies, CPAPs, Critical Thinking & Context

Dismantling diet dogma: Cookies, CPAPs, Critical Thinking & Context

Update: 2025-11-12
Share

Description

In this episode, Erin Power—nutritionist, coach, and the self-proclaimed "hardest-working gal in women’s weight loss" (ha!) —unpacks the noisy, confusing landscape of midlife health advice and helps you find solid ground.

From influencer rabbit holes to viral “lean physique” videos, Erin explains why extreme, aesthetic-driven fitness goals are designed for bodies that make a living being bodies... not for normal women like us.

She shares her personal reflections on time, regret, and influence (yes, even shampoo ads), and introduces a saner path forward: temperate hedonism, where food is both nourishing and enjoyable.

You’ll also hear a powerful client story about redefining progress beyond the bathroom scale and reclaiming health from sleep apnea without chasing an arbitrary “goal weight.”

If you’re ready to trade guilt and extremes for critical thinking, common sense, and results that actually last, this one’s for you.

🎧 Mentioned: The Sugar Short-Circuit (free download) → https://eatsimple.ca/sugar


🧠 Takeaways:

  • Stop confusing fitness with appearance—they’re different pies 🍰

  • Satiety + satisfaction = sustainability

  • You don’t need to “just stop” emotional eating—you need to be fed

  • The scale number is fiction; your clothes, energy, and confidence tell the truth

  • Real change happens when you bring critical thinking and common sense to every message you consume


⏱️ Timestamps / Chapters

00:00   — Introduction: Why November feels like “the moment” for change

01:09   — The Regret List: How Erin tracks wasted time and lessons learned

02:16   — The Drugstore Haircare Rabbit Hole (and what it reveals about influence)

04:40   — How marketers make us buy things we don’t need

05:40   — Instagram’s impact on women’s health decisions

08:01   — The viral “Lean Physique” video and why it hit a nerve

15:53   — Emotional eating, entertainment food, and human wants

21:48   — The Gray Zone: Temperate hedonism and coexistence with cravings

30:50   — Reflecting on old body-image regrets

31:19   — The illusion (and exhaustion) of the “lean physique” life

32:18   — Satiety vs. Satisfaction: Feed your needs and your wants

34:19   — Fitness ≠ Aesthetics: The problem with the “fit look”

38:56   — Why emotional eating doesn’t actually fix emotions

46:59   — The Scale Is Not Your Friend (and never was)

55:57   — The CPAP story: A client’s breakthrough and redefining progress

1:01:10   — Final take: Critical thinking and common sense in a world of noise

Comments 
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Dismantling diet dogma: Cookies, CPAPs, Critical Thinking & Context

Dismantling diet dogma: Cookies, CPAPs, Critical Thinking & Context

Erin Power