DiscoverA Lawyer TalksDon’t go, says ex-judge
Don’t go, says ex-judge

Don’t go, says ex-judge

Update: 2025-09-25
Share

Description

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit rozenberg.substack.com

It would be “shame and a mistake” for the United Kingdom to leave the European convention on human rights, the UK’s former judge at the human rights court told me last week. Tim Eicke KC, who was elected to the court in 2016 for a nine-year-term, spoke to me from Essex Court Chambers, the barristers’ set to which he returned earlier this month.

As the judge “elected in respect of Northern Ireland” — plus the rest of the UK — Eicke (pictured) said he was particularly concerned about the effect that withdrawal from the convention would have on the Belfast Good Friday agreement.

He also referred to a report this month from the Bonavero Institute of Human Rights, which examined how the human rights convention has been covered in the UK. According to the report — but contrary to the impression given by some media outlets — the human rights court had found against the UK in only 13 removal cases since 1980, just four of which concerned family life.

In a wide-ranging interview for A Lawyer Talks, we discussed the government’s plans to limit the application of article 8 of the convention with the aim of deporting more illegal migrants. I also wanted to know why Eicke had applied for the Strasbourg job in the first place and the constraints it had imposed on his return to practice. And he explained why human rights judges from across Europe took such a close interest in the UK.

My regular podcast series is a bonus for paying subscribers to A Lawyer Writes. Non-subscribers can savour a taster by clicking the ► symbol above.

Comments 
loading
In Channel
Consumer protection?

Consumer protection?

2025-10-0100:26

Patently obvious

Patently obvious

2025-09-1500:42

Reform begins at home

Reform begins at home

2025-09-1100:36

Access to justice

Access to justice

2025-09-0100:27

Egging on a pre-nup

Egging on a pre-nup

2025-08-0400:28

Trying rape fairly

Trying rape fairly

2025-07-2200:27

Leveson reports

Leveson reports

2025-07-0900:21

Family law: the future

Family law: the future

2025-07-0400:44

Cyber attacks

Cyber attacks

2025-06-1900:19

A common heritage

A common heritage

2025-06-1251:20

Unlocking the door

Unlocking the door

2025-06-0500:24

Merricks wins £200m

Merricks wins £200m

2025-05-2100:33

Curtailing jury trial

Curtailing jury trial

2025-05-1500:35

Judicial diplomacy

Judicial diplomacy

2025-05-1400:24

Fraudsters beware

Fraudsters beware

2025-04-2400:42

loading
00:00
00:00
1.0x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Don’t go, says ex-judge

Don’t go, says ex-judge

Joshua Rozenberg