Is church membership outdated—or is it the very heart of the Gospel? In this thought-provoking episode of the Circle Dwellers podcast, Matt and Tim Krell unpack why real Christian membership is not about joining an organization, but about entering into covenant relationships that reflect the love of the Trinity itself. From cultural objections about “exclusivity” to the biblical vision of Israel as God’s chosen people, they explore why membership is essential for discipleship, accountability, and true community. Drawing on insights from G.K. Chesterton, church history, and their own Protestant monastic practice, they show how boundaries, commitment, and spiritual formation are vital for becoming the family of God. If you’re a Christian pastor, leader, or layperson who feels dissatisfied with casual, consumer-driven church culture, this episode will challenge you to see membership as the path to real transformation and Christ-centered community.