Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson are sitting on either side of the fire at 221b Baker Street, having a lively discussion. Holmes believes that "life is infinitely stranger than anything which the mind of man could invent," but Watson remains skeptical. As though to prove Holmes right, Miss Mary Sutherland appears at the door. No one knows what has happened to her fiancée and no one seems to care. Holmes has an answer, though it may not be one she can accept...

With special guests Kirby Landers and Sam Murphy.

After the read, Jay and Tony answer listen questions, cast the Muppet's Sherlock Holmes movie, and discuss Conan Doyle's terrible ending to this story.