Martha Mae Butterworth, a spirited and seasoned Christmas enthusiast, offers her heartfelt review of the iconic holiday song "Fairytale of New York" by The Pogues featuring Kirsty MacColl. Through her warm, grandmotherly perspective, she explores the song's unique blend of raw emotion and Christmas spirit, from its unconventional drunk tank opening to its sweeping New York City narrative. Martha Mae's charming commentary weaves together musical analysis with personal anecdotes, explaining how this non-traditional Christmas song captures both the joy and melancholy of the holiday season. Her engaging review celebrates the song's lasting impact while highlighting its authentic portrayal of love, dreams, and disappointment against the backdrop of a Christmas in New York.