Digest

The podcast begins with a discussion about the Dallas Cowboys' recent struggles, particularly their defensive performance. The hosts question whether Jerry Jones should be embarrassed by the team's lack of investment in key positions. The conversation then shifts to Baker Mayfield and his career trajectory, with the hosts debating whether a win against the Philadelphia Eagles would be enough to convince Shady McCoy that he is a truly great quarterback. The hosts delve into the concept of franchise quarterbacks and the expectations that come with being a number one overall pick. They argue that Baker Mayfield has not lived up to the hype and that his performance has been inconsistent. The discussion then explores the impact of environment on talent, using the example of Josh Allen's success with the Buffalo Bills. They argue that even a talented player may struggle in a less-than-ideal environment and that the Cowboys' struggles are not solely due to Jerry Jones. The podcast then focuses on the challenges faced by rookie quarterbacks in the NFL, particularly Caleb Williams and Jayden Daniels. The hosts analyze their performances and the impact of offensive schemes on their success. They also discuss the importance of patience for rookie quarterbacks and the need for veteran players to support them. The conversation shifts to the Buffalo Bills and their success despite having a "bunch of guys" rather than a star-studded receiving corps. The hosts debate whether this approach can lead to a Super Bowl win, with arguments for and against the "bunch of guys" strategy. They use a "chef" analogy to illustrate the importance of the main dog (star player) in a team's success, suggesting that even with a "bunch of guys," a star player can elevate the team's performance. The podcast concludes with a discussion about the Bills' upcoming game against the Ravens, which is seen as a test of their "bunch of guys" approach. The hosts explore whether the Bills can maintain their success against a team with established star players. They also acknowledge that a "bunch of guys" can evolve into "dogs" over time, citing examples from Shady's own career.

Outlines

00:00:00

The Dallas Cowboys' Struggles and the Importance of Franchise Quarterbacks

The podcast begins with a discussion about the Dallas Cowboys' recent struggles, particularly their defensive performance. The hosts question whether Jerry Jones should be embarrassed by the team's lack of investment in key positions. The conversation then shifts to Baker Mayfield and his career trajectory, with the hosts debating whether a win against the Philadelphia Eagles would be enough to convince Shady McCoy that he is a truly great quarterback. The hosts delve into the concept of franchise quarterbacks and the expectations that come with being a number one overall pick. They argue that Baker Mayfield has not lived up to the hype and that his performance has been inconsistent.

00:22:56

Rookie Quarterback Struggles and the Importance of Scheme Fit

The podcast then focuses on the challenges faced by rookie quarterbacks in the NFL, particularly Caleb Williams and Jayden Daniels. The hosts analyze their performances and the impact of offensive schemes on their success. They also discuss the importance of patience for rookie quarterbacks and the need for veteran players to support them. The hosts emphasize the importance of scheme fit for rookie quarterbacks, arguing that it is crucial to put them in a situation where they can succeed. They share anecdotes about Andy Reid and Tom Brady to illustrate the benefits of adapting schemes to a player's strengths.

00:39:35

The "Bunch of Guys" vs. "Dogs" Debate

The conversation shifts to the Buffalo Bills and their success despite having a "bunch of guys" rather than a star-studded receiving corps. The hosts debate whether this approach can lead to a Super Bowl win, with arguments for and against the "bunch of guys" strategy. They use a "chef" analogy to illustrate the importance of the main dog (star player) in a team's success, suggesting that even with a "bunch of guys," a star player can elevate the team's performance.

00:55:29

The Bills' Upcoming Test Against the Ravens and the Evolution of "Dogs"

The podcast concludes with a discussion about the Bills' upcoming game against the Ravens, which is seen as a test of their "bunch of guys" approach. The hosts explore whether the Bills can maintain their success against a team with established star players. They also acknowledge that a "bunch of guys" can evolve into "dogs" over time, citing examples from Shady's own career.

01:11:52

Daniel Jones's Crucial Game Against the Cowboys and Mike Tomlin's Decision on Justin Fields

The hosts discuss the upcoming game between the Giants and Cowboys, highlighting the importance of the game for Daniel Jones's career. They argue that Jones is fighting for his future with the Giants and that a poor performance could lead to the team drafting a new quarterback. The hosts debate Mike Tomlin's decision to not name Justin Fields as the starting quarterback for the Steelers despite his strong performance. They discuss the factors influencing Tomlin's decision, including Russell Wilson's presence and the Steelers' strong defense.

01:27:25

Cowboys' Must-Win Game Against the Giants

The hosts analyze the Cowboys' current situation, emphasizing the importance of their upcoming game against the Giants. They discuss the Cowboys' recent struggles and the potential consequences of a loss, including a three-game losing streak.

Keywords

Q&A

• What are the Dallas Cowboys' biggest weaknesses?

  The Cowboys' biggest weaknesses are their running game on offense and their run defense. They struggle to run the ball effectively and have been unable to stop opposing teams from running the ball.

• Why is Shady McCoy skeptical of Baker Mayfield's ability to be a great quarterback?

  Shady has played with several Super Bowl MVP quarterbacks and has a high standard for what constitutes a great quarterback. He believes that Baker has been inconsistent and has not shown the ability to be a difference-maker.

• What are some of the challenges faced by rookie quarterbacks in the NFL?

  Rookie quarterbacks face many challenges, including adapting to a new level of competition, learning a complex playbook, building chemistry with receivers, and dealing with the pressure of being a high draft pick.

• How can veteran receivers help rookie quarterbacks succeed?

  Veteran receivers can help rookie quarterbacks by being patient, communicating effectively, and building trust. They can also help by simplifying the offense and making plays even when the quarterback is struggling.

• What is the importance of scheme fit for rookie quarterbacks?

  Scheme fit is crucial for rookie quarterbacks because it allows them to play to their strengths and minimize their weaknesses. A good scheme fit can help a rookie quarterback feel more comfortable and confident, leading to better performance.

• Can the Buffalo Bills win a Super Bowl with a "bunch of guys" approach?

  The discussion presents arguments for and against this approach. While the Bills have been successful with a "bunch of guys," some believe that they will need more "dogs" (star players) to win a championship.

• What is the impact of Joe Brady, the Bills' offensive coordinator, on their success?

  Brady's focus on running the ball and protecting Josh Allen has led to a more balanced and efficient offense, taking pressure off Allen and allowing him to play at a higher level.

• How important is it to have star players in the NFL?

  The discussion emphasizes the importance of star players, particularly in the playoffs and Super Bowl. Star players can elevate the team's performance and make a significant difference in high-pressure situations.

• What is the difference between a "bunch of guys" and "dogs" in the NFL?

  "Dogs" are star players who are highly skilled and impactful, while "guys" are capable players who contribute to success but are not considered superstars. The presence of "dogs" is often seen as crucial for championship success.

• How can a "bunch of guys" evolve into "dogs"?

  The discussion suggests that "guys" can develop into "dogs" over time through hard work, experience, and opportunities. The Bills' current "bunch of guys" have the potential to become star players in the future.

• What is the significance of the Bills' upcoming game against the Ravens?

  This game is seen as a test of the Bills' "bunch of guys" approach against a team with established star players. The outcome will provide valuable insights into the Bills' potential for championship success.

• What is at stake for Daniel Jones in the upcoming game against the Cowboys?

  Daniel Jones's career is at stake. A poor performance could lead to the Giants drafting a new quarterback, potentially ending his time with the team.

• Why is Mike Tomlin hesitant to name Justin Fields as the starting quarterback for the Steelers?

  Tomlin is hesitant because Russell Wilson is still on the roster and is expected to return from injury. Additionally, the Steelers' strong defense has been a major factor in their success, making the quarterback position less crucial.

• Is the Cowboys' game against the Giants a must-win game?

  Yes, the Cowboys are on the verge of a three-game losing streak and need a win to avoid falling further behind in their division. A loss could have significant consequences for their playoff aspirations.

Show Notes