Gambling on Elections, What Could Go Wrong?
Digest
This podcast delves into the world of prediction markets, focusing on Polymarket, a platform where users can bet on various events, including political outcomes. The episode traces the history of these markets, highlighting early examples like the Iowa Electronic Markets and Predicted. It examines the factors contributing to Polymarket's popularity, including its association with the crypto boom and its growing legitimacy in the media. The podcast discusses the increasing media attention Polymarket is receiving, including Nate Silver's involvement as an advisor and investor. It raises ethical concerns about prediction markets, questioning whether the profit motive can lead to perverse incentives and highlighting examples of manipulation. The episode connects the rise of prediction markets to the broader cultural shift towards gambling, including sports betting, crypto, and meme stocks. It discusses the regulatory landscape surrounding prediction markets, highlighting the role of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and the legal battles surrounding their operation. The podcast examines the potential right-wing bias in prediction markets and discusses Polymarket's efforts to diversify its user base. It concludes by discussing the potential consequences of prediction markets, including the risk of manipulation, the potential for financial ruin for gamblers, and the overall impact on the political landscape.
Outlines
The Rise of Prediction Markets
This episode introduces the concept of prediction markets, focusing on Polymarket and its use for betting on political outcomes. It explores the potential of these markets as political indicators and the ethical concerns surrounding them.
History and Early Examples
The conversation delves into the history of prediction markets, highlighting the Iowa Electronic Markets and Predicted, established for research purposes. It focuses on the research goals and motivations behind these early markets.
Polymarket's Popularity and Legitimacy
This episode examines the factors contributing to Polymarket's popularity, including its association with the crypto boom, its use of stablecoins, and its growing legitimacy in the media. It highlights specific events that solidified Polymarket's reputation as a political forecaster.
Prediction Markets and the Culture of Gambling
The episode connects the rise of prediction markets to the broader cultural shift towards gambling, including sports betting, crypto, and meme stocks. It explores the potential for irrational behavior and the challenges of regulating these markets.
Keywords
Prediction Market
A platform where individuals can buy and sell contracts that pay out based on the outcome of future events, such as elections, sporting events, or economic indicators. These markets are often used to gauge public sentiment and forecast future outcomes.
Polymarket
A prediction market platform that allows users to bet on a wide range of events, including political outcomes, pop culture trends, and even the existence of aliens. It has gained significant attention for its accuracy in forecasting political events.
Stablecoin
A type of cryptocurrency that is pegged to the value of a fiat currency, such as the US dollar. Stablecoins are designed to reduce volatility and provide a more stable store of value compared to other cryptocurrencies.
Perverse Incentive
A reward system that encourages behavior that is contrary to the intended outcome. In the context of prediction markets, perverse incentives can arise when individuals are motivated by profit rather than accuracy or ethical considerations.
Meme Stock
A stock that has gained popularity and increased in value due to social media hype and retail investor interest, often driven by online communities and forums. Meme stocks are often characterized by high volatility and speculative trading.
Cryptocurrency
A digital or virtual currency that uses cryptography for security and operates independently of central banks. Cryptocurrencies are often decentralized, meaning they are not subject to government control.
Lobbying
The act of attempting to influence the decisions of government officials, often by providing information or advocating for a particular policy. Lobbying is a common practice in many countries, and it can be used to influence legislation, regulations, and other government actions.
Right-Wing Bias
A tendency to favor conservative or right-leaning political views. In the context of prediction markets, right-wing bias can manifest in the demographics of users, the types of events that are traded, and the overall political sentiment reflected in the market.
Q&A
What are prediction markets and how do they work?
Prediction markets are platforms where individuals can buy and sell contracts that pay out based on the outcome of future events. Users can bet on various events, such as elections, sporting events, or economic indicators. The price of a contract reflects the market's collective belief about the likelihood of a particular outcome.
What are some of the ethical concerns surrounding prediction markets?
One concern is that the profit motive can lead to perverse incentives, where individuals are motivated by personal gain rather than accuracy or ethical considerations. There is also a risk of manipulation, where individuals or groups may attempt to influence the market to their advantage.
How have prediction markets gained legitimacy in the media and among political observers?
Prediction markets have gained attention for their accuracy in forecasting political events. Some prominent figures, such as Nate Silver, have recognized their potential as a valuable tool for understanding public sentiment and predicting election outcomes.
What are the potential consequences of prediction markets for the political landscape?
The injection of personal profit motives into politics could lead to increased manipulation and influence peddling. There is also a risk that individuals may be tempted to bet on real-life events, potentially leading to dangerous or unethical behavior.
Show Notes
Forget polls—are gambling websites the real way to predict politics?
Guest: Nitish Pahwa, business and tech writer at Slate
Want more What Next? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Table of contents
United States
The proliferation of all types of sanctioned gambling in the last few years is shocking. Is it possible many people are just hoping their opinions will create a big payoff, rather than engaging in their actual lives to impact outcomes?