After calling the game and watching the tape, Bob Papa and Carl Banks discuss the Giants’ tough defensive showing in their recent loss to Philadelphia. They talk about the struggles with run defense, missed tackles, and how key players like Dexter Lawrence fell short. They also mention issues with officiating, coaching, and accountability, and share what the team needs to focus on in the next nine weeks.

00:01:17

Poor officiating across the NFL, how league decision-makers influence calls, and the impact on games, including the Giants’ loss.

00:04:40

Tush Push and ball fumble

00:07:33

Carl reflects on team mentality, responsibility, and lack of execution by this year’s defense.

00:10:33

Dexter Lawrence ‘s performance

00:13:49

Break down missed assignments by linebackers and defensive scheme; dissecting Saquon Barkley’s big run and mistakes in gap discipline.

00:16:02

Frustration about defensive tackling: coaches’ and players’ shared responsibility when routine plays go wrong

00:18:07

Bob asks about personnel issues and repetitive defensive breakdowns versus tight ends in the red zone; Carl connects missed assignments to coaching and players.

00:21:38

Discussion of backup and practice squad players

00:24:52

Play breakdowns continue: secondary’s role on Barkley’s touchdown run, gap fits, safety and linebackers’ missed reads.

00:28:48

Carl sharply critiques defensive effort and pride—compares offensive improvement to defensive regression.

00:32:21

Highlights coaching successes on offense (wide receivers/tight ends adjusting after injuries) versus lack of defensive impact from high-profile players.

00:33:51

Praises offensive line for neutralizing Jalen Carter; contrasts offensive and defensive position group performances.

00:35:15

Returns to questionable officiating. Slayton DPI/OPI call; possible hip drop tackle on Cam Skattebo, and how league safety rules affect play.

00:41:07

Depth chart and injury impact

00:43:02

Call for accountability: nine weeks left for coaches/players to prove they belong in the NFL and save their jobs.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.