Joker: Folie à Deux is a follow-up that takes the foundations of 2019’s Joker and, quite frankly, leaves them in the dust. Directed once again by Todd Phillips, this sequel trades in the raw, grounded intensity of the first film for a flashy, surreal spectacle that feels jarringly out of place. Where Joker delivered a chilling psychological portrait of Arthur Fleck’s descent into madness, Folie à Deux seems content with superficial theatrics and stylistic excess, abandoning the careful character work that made Arthur’s story so compelling.

The most controversial creative choice here? It has to be the musical element, which feels entirely at odds with the film’s established tone. Instead of maintaining the gritty, unnerving realism that defined Arthur’s journey, Phillips dives headfirst into a musical fantasy. This choice doesn’t just feel unexpected—it feels unearned. The inclusion of song and dance numbers, mainly to explore Arthur’s connection to Harley Quinn (played by Lady Gaga), strips away much of the intensity that defined the original, leaving us with a tonal clash that undermines the story's impact.

Speaking of Harley, Lady Gaga is a powerhouse performer, and her casting could have been an exciting way to explore a fascinating and complex character. However, the film doesn’t do her justice. Rather than giving us a nuanced, intricate look at Harley and Arthur’s relationship, Folie à Deux opts for surface-level theatrics that barely scratch the depth these characters deserve. While intriguing, the chemistry between Phoenix and Gaga is undercut by a script that treats their dynamic as little more than a visually striking spectacle rather than a fully developed relationship. Instead of a true exploration of love and chaos, what we get feels like a stylised portrayal of toxic romance without the emotional weight needed to make it resonate.

It’s disappointing to see Phillips drift so far from the gritty realism that defined Joker. The first film was a brutal examination of a broken man shaped by a broken world, blending tragedy and horror with an uncomfortably close-to-home critique of society. In Folie à Deux, however, Arthur’s journey seems almost incidental, overshadowed by Phillips’ desire to create something visually bold and tonally eclectic. We’re left with a spectacle, but not the kind that delivers any true insight or depth.

Overall, Joker: Folie à Deux feels more concerned with aesthetics than substance. The unsettling descent into madness that Joker perfected is sacrificed here, replaced by a style-over-story approach that feels, at best, a creative gamble that didn’t pay off. Fans hoping for a continuation of Arthur Fleck’s dark, unflinching narrative may find themselves disappointed as this sequel veers wildly off course, trading a complex character study for flashy, hollow musical numbers and a superficial take on love and chaos.

If you loved the gritty, psychologically charged experience of the first Joker, this follow-up might leave you wondering why Phillips chose to take Arthur’s story in such a drastically different and ultimately less impactful direction.

Please follow the Podcast and join our community at 

https://linktr.ee/borntowatchpodcast

https://www.borntowatch.com.au/