Have you ever cheered when a scammer got scammed?
Have you ever laughed when an anti-LGBTQ politician was caught in a gay sex scandal?

That little thrill you feel isn’t random — it’s human nature. Across every culture, every story, every fairy tale, the lesson is the same: actions have consequences. The lazy pigs lose their houses. The greedy villain is crushed. We love seeing people get their just desserts.

But here’s the uncomfortable truth: that same instinct shapes the way we think about sexual health.

It’s not just sex-positive folks who struggle with this. Everyone — no matter their values — has moments where they take satisfaction in watching someone they deem “sluttier” or “more reckless” pay a price. We laugh, we moralize, we gossip. Why? Because deep down, punishment feels like justice.

And yet, science has changed the game. With tools like PrEP, DoxyPEP, and multi-site STI testing, people can dramatically reduce risk. But instead of celebrating that progress, many people feel uneasy. Even those who champion sexual freedom get uncomfortable when others skip condoms but stay covered through modern medicine. Why? Because it feels like cheating the system — like breaking the rules without facing consequences.

In this episode of the Shameless Care Podcast, Robert and Anna dig into the psychology of punishment, fairness, and why humans crave “just desserts.” From schadenfreude to sexual ethics, we explore how this ancient instinct influences modern public health and the way we talk about sex.

We tackle the tough questions:
•Why do we secretly want “rule breakers” to get sick?
•Do we actually care about safety, or do we want to see punishment?
•If consequences disappear, do the rules still matter?
•And what does all of this mean for the future of sexual health?

From fairy tales to politics to the bedroom, this episode will make you laugh, cringe, and think differently about why we want people to pay the price for what we judge as “bad behavior.”

👉 Listen now to Just Desserts: Why We Secretly Want Sinners to Get Sick — only on the Shameless Care Podcast.