Love Island Games Season 2 Finale Recap

Hosted by Kirsten MacInnis and Scally, your ultimate villa besties, this podcast dives deep into Love Island Games Season 2. Kirsten and Scally are here with hilarious commentary and all the piping-hot takes you crave.

Welcome back to the We Know Love Island podcast on RHAP!

After weeks of twists, tears, and betrayals, Love Island Games Season 2 has finally come to a dramatic close—and Kirsten McKinnis and Brian Scally are here to break it all down on We Know Love Island!

In this finale recap, the hosts dive headfirst into the chaos of the last few episodes, starting with the infamous Casino Night and the basketball challenge that cemented the power of the main alliance. With the alliance carrying all the way to the final four, Kirsten and Scally reflect on how strategy—not just romance—shaped the season and why future Islanders should take notes.

Of course, the drama didn’t stop there. From Josh’s sulky exit after he and Andrea were dumped, to Johnny and Gabby’s shocking elimination by America’s vote, the tension leading up to the Mega Duel was high. Kirsten shares her relief at Johnny’s downfall, contrasting his gameplay with Justine’s authenticity.

The finale showdown itself brought big stakes: first, the puzzling Towers of Trust that tripped up Toby and Sydney, and then “The Heist,” a gritty scramble for the $250,000 prize. Despite Justine and Tyreek’s fan-favorite status, Isaiah and Lucinda outlasted the competition, with Isaiah’s physical edge making the difference. In the end, the winning couple both chose “love” and split the money—a rare but heartwarming outcome.

Kirsten and Scally close by making bold predictions about which couples might actually survive the off-season, and who deserves a redemption arc if Love Island Games returns for Season 3.

LISTEN: Subscribe to the We Know Love Island podcast feed!
WATCH: Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT: Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices