Digest

The podcast dives into a comprehensive discussion about quarterbacks, ranking them based on their skill, potential, and performance in high-pressure situations. The hosts begin by establishing their criteria for ranking quarterbacks, emphasizing the importance of playoff performance and surrounding circumstances. They then create a tier list, starting with the top tier of elite quarterbacks and working their way down to the "Great Backup Quarterback" tier. The hosts discuss the placement of various quarterbacks, including Aaron Rodgers, Kirk Cousins, Kyler Murray, and Baker Mayfield, analyzing their strengths and weaknesses. They also create a new tier for young quarterbacks who have yet to prove themselves, the "Rookie Until You're Not" tier, which includes players like Caleb Williams, Bo Nix, and Anthony Richardson. The conversation then shifts to the "Great Backup Quarterback" tier, where the hosts discuss the potential of players like Sam Darnold and Marcus Mariota. They also delve into the future of Daniel Jones, debating whether he should be considered a "great backup" or a "rookie until he's not." Finally, the hosts finalize their quarterback tier list, placing players like Dak Prescott, Joe Flacco, and Zach Wilson in various categories. They conclude the episode by discussing the rationale behind their decisions and highlighting the quarterbacks who stand out in each category.

Outlines

00:00:00

Quarterback Tier List and Criteria

The hosts introduce the concept of a quarterback tier list and outline their criteria for ranking players, emphasizing playoff performance and surrounding circumstances.

00:02:40

Elite Quarterbacks and the "Joe Flacco" Tier

The hosts begin creating a tier list, starting with the top tier of elite quarterbacks and discussing the placement of Aaron Rodgers in the "Joe Flacco" tier, which represents quarterbacks who could go on a run but are not considered elite.

00:41:31

The "Horrified in a Playoff Game" Tier

The hosts discuss the "Horrified in a Playoff Game" tier, which includes quarterbacks who are not considered reliable in high-pressure situations, starting with Kirk Cousins and Kyler Murray.

00:51:07

The "Rookie Until You're Not" Tier

The hosts create a new tier for young quarterbacks who have yet to prove themselves, including Caleb Williams, Bo Nix, and Anthony Richardson.

00:54:32

The "Great Backup Quarterback" Tier

The hosts discuss the "Great Backup Quarterback" tier, which includes quarterbacks who are considered capable backups but not starting material, starting with Sam Darnold and Baker Mayfield.

01:00:10

Ranking Quarterbacks: Great Backups and Rookies

The discussion focuses on ranking quarterbacks, specifically identifying those who are considered "great backups" and "rookies until they're not." The conversation delves into the performance and potential of various quarterbacks, including Sean Watson, Bryce Young, Will Levis, and Daniel Jones.

01:04:38

Finalizing the Quarterback Tier List

The speakers finalize their quarterback tier list, placing players like Dak Prescott, Joe Flacco, and Zach Wilson in various categories. They discuss the criteria for each tier and the rationale behind their decisions.

01:05:36

Tier List Discussion and Conclusion

The speakers discuss the final tier list, highlighting the quarterbacks who stand out in each category. They conclude the episode by promoting their other content and thanking listeners for joining them.

Keywords

Q&A

• What are the hosts' criteria for ranking quarterbacks?

  The hosts consider a quarterback's skill, potential, and performance in high-pressure situations, particularly in playoff games. They also acknowledge the importance of surrounding circumstances, such as the quality of the team and coaching staff.

• What is the "Joe Flacco" tier?

  The "Joe Flacco" tier represents quarterbacks who have the potential to go on a run but are not considered elite. These quarterbacks are capable of surprising performances but may not be consistently reliable in high-pressure situations.

• Why is Kyler Murray placed in the "Horrified in a Playoff Game" tier?

  Kyler Murray is placed in this tier due to concerns about his durability. While he is an electric player when healthy, his small stature and history of injuries make him a risky proposition in high-pressure situations.

• What is the "Rookie Until You're Not" tier?

  This tier is for young quarterbacks who have yet to prove themselves. These players have high upside but need to demonstrate their ability to perform consistently at the professional level.

• What is the "Great Backup Quarterback" tier?

  This tier represents quarterbacks who are considered capable backups but not starting material. These players may have flashes of brilliance but lack the consistency or overall skill to be considered elite.

• What criteria are used to determine whether a quarterback is a "great backup" or a "rookie until they're not"?

  The criteria include experience, performance, potential, and the overall perception of the quarterback's ability to contribute to a team.

• How does Daniel Jones's recent contract and past injuries potentially impact his confidence?

  The speakers express concern that the pressure of a large contract and the lingering effects of injuries could negatively impact Jones's confidence, even if he has the physical ability to perform well.

• What are the key factors that determine a quarterback's placement on the final tier list?

  The speakers consider factors such as past performance, potential, current team situation, and overall perception of the quarterback's ability to succeed.

Show Notes