Dr. Chino discusses the past, present, and future of prior authorization in cancer care with Dr. Michael Anne Kyle, a health policy expert with a research focus on utilization management and patient burdens from prior auth.

TRANSCRIPT 

Dr. Fumiko Chino: Hello and welcome to Put Into Practice, the podcast for the JCO Oncology Practice. I'm Dr. Fumiko Chino, an Assistant Professor in Radiation Oncology at MD Anderson Cancer Center with a research focus on access, affordability and equity.

On today's episode we'll be discussing prior authorization in cancer care. Prior auth has been a recent focus of healthcare policy and reform, given rising demands seen by both providers and patients. I'm excited to welcome an expert on prior authorization to the podcast today. Dr. Michael Anne Kyle is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy at the Perelman School of Medicine at UPenn. Her work focuses on defining and measuring patient administrative burden in cancer care delivery with a focus on prior authorization and how it impacts cancer care delivery, including patient wellbeing and outcomes. She holds a Ph.D. from the Harvard Business School, an MPH from the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, and a Master's in Nursing from the UPenn.

Our full disclosures are available in the transcript of this episode, and we've all already agreed to go by our first names for the podcast today.

Michael Anne, it's so great to speak with you today.

Dr. Michael Anne Kyle: It is so great to speak with you too, Fumiko. I'm really excited about this conversation and our shared interest in improving prior authorization.

Dr. Fumiko Chino: I love it that you've taken time out of your day to talk to me.

To start us off, can you tell us a little bit about yourself and your career? How did you transition from being a nurse into a health policy researcher? Did you always plan on a career in research or was there some specific event or transition that put you on this path?

Dr. Michael Anne Kyle: There was not. And so for anyone who's listening, who isn't sure what they want to do, I guess I have a good story to show that you actually don't need to know in advance. I started out as a critical care nurse and I still actually work as a critical care nurse. But as I think anyone who is a clinician who's listening to this knows, when you work in the healthcare system you just see so many things that could be different, that could be better. You notice the ways that the systems like really aren't set up for us to do our work or to take great care of our patients some of the time. And so that's really what sparked my interest in policy and in research. So I had really no background.

After working in a hospital, high acuity critical care, a lot of oncology, I spent several years working in community-based programs in New Jersey and this is before the Affordable Care Act. We were focused on access to medication, trying to get people more access to Medicaid, and did work around the initial rollout of the Affordable Care Act. And that experience where I spent a lot of time helping people enroll in social programs really gave me like some of the first insights into how much paperwork and how much time and how tedious it is to figure a lot of this out, even if you had someone helping you it's still challenging. And that sort of stayed in the back of my mind as I went to grad school. And really what got me interested in like all the non-medical side of patient care is just like my friends and my family talking to me about it. And I think it's something we all just experience in our lives, but there just wasn't a ton of research. And so I've really been motivated to try to put some, like, numbers and evidence beside all these experiences that we know very deeply.

Dr. Fumiko Chino: So what I'm hearing is that you learned yourself by doing the work, how difficult the work was to actually obtain services for your patients, and so you decided you needed to go upstream to try to address some of the policies that were fundamentally broken, causing these horrible situations for your patients.

Dr. Michael Anne Kyle: So well said. Yes.

Dr. Fumiko Chino: Now, I heard that you just moved from Boston to Philly. How's that transition going?

Dr. Michael Anne Kyle: It's great, it's great. Many of the same familiar faces and also exciting to meet new people, learn new things, try new restaurants. So yeah, overall I feel very lucky.

Dr. Fumiko Chino: Well, with that background, we need to dive into our actual topic, which is prior authorization. It's unlikely that anyone listening to this podcast has not encountered prior authorization in their practice or due to interactions with insurance for themselves or for their family members. Can you give me a quick overview about prior authorization? What it is, what it is not, how did we get here?

Dr. Michael Anne Kyle: Oh, so every healthcare system needs some sort of coverage policy. What services are we going to cover and at what cost? And there's many ways to do this. There are countries that sort of set this up nationally. Here in the US, we do not do that. We do it prescription by prescription, and that's how we end up with prior authorization. So basically, prior authorization is a request you submit to get approval for coverage for a drug or a service that you want to give your patient. And so you may need to submit, and again, I'm sure everyone listening knows this well, but it can range for something very quick like, "Yes, this person has like the genetic target for this drug. Check, they can have it," or it can be a more complex, protracted exchange. That is the sort of intellectual side of this. And I want to separate that from like the actual decision making from the other huge piece of prior authorization, which is how we operate it. And that is the bureaucracy and the fax machines and the time on hold, which has a separate bucket of problems. And so I just want to sort of carve out those two categories when I think about prior auth and what we need to do.

Dr. Fumiko Chino: One thing I always try to say is that even with prior authorization, even when it is working as functions, it is itself not a guarantee that a claim is even going to be approved. You can obtain prior authorization and then still face a denial for the actual claim, which is even more frustrating. And I think this kind of cumulative burden of suffering seems to me to be at an all-time peak. So can you give me a little bit of background about how the US healthcare system evolved to include prior aut