The reconsideration of value is a formal process.  In the Fannie Mae Selling Guide are the guidelines that allows a lender or borrower to request a review of an appraisal when relevant new information may affect the value opinion. This isn’t about disagreeing with the appraiser’s judgment.  It’s about presenting factual, material data—such as overlooked property features or newly closed comparable sales—that may not have been available during the original analysis. The appraiser then reviews this information and determines whether it justifies any change to the original value.

A reconsideration of value must be supported by specific, verifiable market data.  It cannot be based on mere dissatisfaction with the appraised value. The appraiser’s role is to assess the credibility and relevance of the submitted information. If the new data is meaningful and meets professional standards, the appraiser may issue a revised report. However, if the appraiser finds the information immaterial or redundant, the original value opinion stands.  This reinforces the objectivity and independence of the appraisal process.

The reconsideration of value request typically must be submitted within 30 days of the appraisal’s delivery.  Only the borrower can initiate it. Appraisers are prohibited from making changes based solely on client preferences or pressure. The process safeguards the reliability of valuation in mortgage lending.  It also offers a mechanism to correct genuine oversights. When properly handled, it ensures fair and accurate appraisals without compromising professional ethics or regulatory compliance.

And don’t forget to keep your E&O Insurance up to date and a great administrative law attorney on  your side!