DiscoverPhilosophical ProblemsSelf Identity, Part II
Self Identity, Part II

Self Identity, Part II

Update: 2013-03-20
Share

Description

Does it make sense to think we can duplicate persons, so that people can divide just like cells? Since splitting means dividing one person into two people, the obvious answer seems to be that persons are unable to undergo fission. By looking at the old example of the Ship of Theseus we find that it is possible to think of artefacts dividing, in that one ship can become two. More precisely, a set of time-slices that constitute one ship can be shared by two different future sets of time slices that constitute two different ships. Exactly the same can be said of person fission of the sort that could happen using Star-Trek-style teleporter technology.



Copyright 2013 Jack Reynolds / La Trobe University, all rights reserved. Contact for permissions.

Comments 
In Channel
Free Will II

Free Will II

2013-05-2250:47

Free Will I

Free Will I

2013-05-2050:53

Other Minds

Other Minds

2013-04-3048:46

Brain-snatched II

Brain-snatched II

2013-04-1851:54

Brain-snatched I

Brain-snatched I

2013-04-1649:22

Self Identity, Part II

Self Identity, Part II

2013-03-2042:22

Self Identity, Part I

Self Identity, Part I

2013-03-2044:59

Time Travel, Part II

Time Travel, Part II

2013-03-1246:08

Time Travel, Part I

Time Travel, Part I

2013-03-1242:34

What is Philosophy?

What is Philosophy?

2013-03-0521:36

00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Self Identity, Part II

Self Identity, Part II

Professor Andrew Brennan