Listen Top Shows Blog

Shevuot 34: Why oaths of testimony apply solely in monetary cases

Shevuot 34: Why oaths of testimony apply solely in monetary cases

Update: 2018-01-01

Share

Description

Braita with four Tannaitic opinions on why oaths of testimony apply solely to monetary cases (33b-34a); 2) R' Eliezer's approach: highlighting the similarities between oaths of testimony and oaths of deposit (34a); 3) R' Akiva: not fundamentally disagreeing with R' Eliezer (34a); 4) R' Yosi Haglili: Why we allow the most circumstantial evidence for monetary cases (34a); 5) Two cases of impartial testimony (34a-34b).

Click here to read the source sheet

Click here for the board layout

Rabbi Eli Yoggev can be reached for questions and comments at eyoggev@btfiloh.org.

Comments

In Channel

Shevuot 49: Monetary loss as the source of liability for an Oath of Deposit

Shevuot 49: Monetary loss as the source of liability for an Oath of Deposit

2018-01-1656:32

Shevuot 48: Can an oath be inherited? Shmuel vs. R' Elazar

Shevuot 48: Can an oath be inherited? Shmuel vs. R' Elazar

2018-01-1555:19

Shevuot 47: Alternatives to oaths for those suspected of false oaths

Shevuot 47: Alternatives to oaths for those suspected of false oaths

2018-01-1401:00:42

Shevuot 45: The oath of a hired worker and its laws

Shevuot 45: The oath of a hired worker and its laws

2018-01-1201:01:08

Shevuot 44: The purpose of a collateral

Shevuot 44: The purpose of a collateral

2018-01-1156:49

Shevuot 43: Why we don't make oaths on land

Shevuot 43: Why we don't make oaths on land

2018-01-1001:00:13

Shevuot 42: The role of a minor in oaths

Shevuot 42: The role of a minor in oaths

2018-01-0957:19

Shevuot 41: Between biblical and rabbinic oaths

Shevuot 41: Between biblical and rabbinic oaths

2018-01-0801:03:51

Shevuot 40: Minimal amount of denial for an oath of the judges

Shevuot 40: Minimal amount of denial for an oath of the judges

2018-01-0701:02:53

(End of) Shevuot 37: On the validity of land oaths of deposit (Daf 38 & 39 delivered over Shabbat)

(End of) Shevuot 37: On the validity of land oaths of deposit (Daf 38 & 39 delivered over Shabbat)

2018-01-0520:29

Shevuot 37: Punishment for an oath of deposit accompanied by warning/witnesses

Shevuot 37: Punishment for an oath of deposit accompanied by warning/witnesses

2018-01-0457:38

Shevuot 36: Language of oaths & intro. to oaths of deposit

Shevuot 36: Language of oaths & intro. to oaths of deposit

2018-01-0359:42

Shevuot 35: Names of God: Oaths, definition, placement in Torah

Shevuot 35: Names of God: Oaths, definition, placement in Torah

2018-01-0201:06:53

Shevuot 34: Why oaths of testimony apply solely in monetary cases

Shevuot 34: Why oaths of testimony apply solely in monetary cases

2018-01-0101:02:26

Shevuot 33: Do penalties incur liability for oaths of testimony?

Shevuot 33: Do penalties incur liability for oaths of testimony?

2017-12-3101:00:40

Shevuot 31: How to steer clear of deceitful situations

Shevuot 31: How to steer clear of deceitful situations

2017-12-2901:04:44

Shevuot 30: Women & Testimony; Standing During Testimony

Shevuot 30: Women & Testimony; Standing During Testimony

2017-12-2801:02:20

Shevuot 29: Vain Oaths and Adjuration by Others

Shevuot 29: Vain Oaths and Adjuration by Others

2017-12-2701:03:14

Shevuot 28: Suspended, extended, and conditional oaths

Shevuot 28: Suspended, extended, and conditional oaths

2017-12-2601:02:48

Shevuot 27: On making an oath against the Torah

Shevuot 27: On making an oath against the Torah

2017-12-2555:01

00:00

00:00

x

Shevuot 34: Why oaths of testimony apply solely in monetary cases

Shevuot 34: Why oaths of testimony apply solely in monetary cases

Rabbi Eli Yoggev