How do you build a nation from scratch? The founders didn't work in a vacuum—they had living laboratories in the form of state constitutions. These documents, written during the revolutionary fervor after 1776, provided crucial lessons about what worked—and what spectacularly failed—in constitutional design.

Dr. Beienberg walks us through the fascinating contrast between two state constitutions that shaped America's founding document. The Pennsylvania Constitution 1776, drafted in revolutionary excitement, created an overly responsive system with minimal checks on popular will. Madison and other founders viewed it as a cautionary tale of democratic excess, famously referring to it as the "don't do that one, kids" example. Its unicameral legislature, weak executive, and limited judicial independence demonstrated how "parchment barriers" alone couldn't prevent tyranny or bad governance.

On the opposite end stood the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780, primarily crafted by John Adams. This document reflected a more realistic view of human nature, establishing stronger separation of powers, bicameralism, and judicial independence. Its robust bill of rights directly influenced the U.S. Bill of Rights, while its popular ratification process became the model for legitimizing the federal Constitution. This tension between Pennsylvania's optimistic view of human virtue and Massachusetts' more cautious approach reveals the philosophical underpinnings of American constitutionalism.

These state-level experiments provided the founders with real-world evidence about constitutional design. They showed that written constitutions could work as supreme laws while highlighting the importance of institutional checks on power. Rather than simply theorizing about government, they analyzed existing models to create something more enduring. Listen as we uncover how these forgotten state constitutions shaped the document that governs America today.

Check Out the Civic Literacy Curriculum!

School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership

Center for American Civics