Stop Losing Leads! Simple Automations and Resource Guides for Insurance Agents

If you’re an insurance agent juggling client calls, marketing events, and the endless tasks that build your business, you’re not alone. In this episode of the Insurance Business Babes podcast, hosts Joanna Wyckoff sits down with guest Kimberly to pull back the curtain on the real, messy process behind scaling a successful insurance business in the Medicare space. Here’s what we learned.

Streamlining Your Marketing and Client Onboarding

Kimberly shared her grassroots approach to Medicare marketing—hosting T65 educational events, leveraging referrals, and joining local coalitions. But the hands-on work (think DIY mailers with help from family) also highlighted how easily things slip through the cracks, especially when follow-ups are delayed and reminders are missed.

Joanna emphasized the power of systematizing these touchpoints. By integrating technology—like permission-to-contact QR codes and electronic intake forms—lead data automatically enters your CRM instead of disappearing in an unread text or paper stack. This keeps prospects organized, timely, and visible for both you and your team.

Buy Back Your Time With Virtual Assistants

One of Joanna’s most actionable tips? Hire a virtual assistant (VA)—even if just for 20 hours a week, and even on a shoestring budget. VAs in the Philippines or Jamaica with insurance experience can handle calls, texts, follow-ups, and administrative tasks for about $4 an hour. The key is to first adopt a VOIP system (like Dialpad, RingCentral, or GoHighLevel) so your VA can work from anywhere and manage communications seamlessly—freeing you to focus on revenue-generating activities.

Embrace Digital Calendars and Remote Sales

Kimberly admitted her reluctance to abandon face-to-face appointments for phone or Zoom meetings, especially in rural markets. Joanna’s advice was clear: transitioning even some appointments to digital not only boosts efficiency, but also meets today’s seniors where they’re increasingly comfortable—on their smartphones.

To truly scale, move away from paper calendars and manual scheduling. Digital calendars (even paired with printed versions for the visual folks!) allow your staff to coordinate and block out time, ensuring nothing falls through the cracks and growth stays manageable.

Stand Out with Educational Resource Guides

Finally, giving clients an educational resource guide—customized with your branding and a QR code linking to your intake process—cements your expertise far more than a business card ever will. It shows clients you’re organized, informed, and invested in helping them understand their options, all while keeping your information handy for referrals.

Conclusion

Ready to stop losing leads? Use the tips from this episode: implement smart tech, delegate wisely, transition to digital where possible, and create tangible resources for your clients. These small changes will help you manage, grow, and love your insurance business—all without burning out.

This episode is sponsored by ⁠CertifiedMedicareAgents.com⁠. Use the coupon code BABES2024 for a free lifetime BRONZE membership.