This is a band that defined early 2000s emo for so many (including us). And it turns out the band drama was even messier than their lyrics. It's TAKING BACK SUNDAY week!

The guys have an important show announcement up top before reexamining their short-lived intense fandom with these Long Island heroes. It takes a while to get through the early rise and messy bitch drama of Tell All Your Friends before we get to some performances, including an era-defining acoustic performance on Last Call with Carson Daly. Alex and Jon discover they remembered this band all wrong with the two-album run of Fred Mascherino being by far the best era of the band. And stick around for a critical analysis of Denny's 2008 emo/screamo adopt-a-band all nighter menu featuring a Hoobastank burrito.

Want to watch along with us? Check out the links below for the performances discussed this week!

Cute Without the E (Cut From the Team)/Message in a Bottle, 9/9/2003 on Jimmy Kimmel Live!

You're So Last Summer, 11/11/2003 on Last Call with Carson Daly

A Decade Under the Influence, 10/8/2004 on The Late Late Show with Craig Ferguson

MakeDamnSure, 7/24/2006 on The Tonight Show with Jay Leno

Liar (It Takes One to Know One), 12/20/2006 on The Late Show with David Letterman

Sink Into Me/New Again, 6/2/2009 on Jimmy Kimmel Live!

Better Homes and Gardens with the Contemporary Youth Orchestra, 7/22/2015 on The Alternative Press Music Awards