Texas, 1988. We dig into the San Angelo case of Sally McNelly & Shane Stewart—fireworks at Lake Nasworthy, a Camaro that turns up miles away, and a chilling aftermath that collided with the late-’80s Satanic Panic. Straight timeline, hard facts, and the most plausible theories—no fluff, just everything that still doesn’t add up.

BetterHelp — This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Get matched with a licensed therapist entirely online—fill out a brief questionnaire and switch therapists anytime. Start today at bettehelp.com/brohio

DraftKings Casino — Download the DraftKings Casino app and play slots, blackjack, and live-dealer games. Sign up with code BROHIOPODCAST to get your offer.
21+. Physically present in eligible states only (e.g., NJ/PA/MI/CT/WV). Eligibility restrictions apply. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER (NJ/PA/WV/MI), 888-789-7777 (CT), or visit 1800GAMBLER.net.