Listen Top Shows Blog

The Dilemma of Handing Over One to Save Many

The Dilemma of Handing Over One to Save Many

Update: 2025-06-20

Share

Description

Can a Jewish community surrender one of its own to save the many? This class explores three cases from the 1600s and 1700s, where this wrenching question was brought before leading rabbanim. We’ll learn about the details of each case, the rulings the rabbis issued, and the Talmudic sources that shaped their decisions.

The Dilemma of Handing Over One to Save Many

Comments

In Channel

We’ve Been Singing It All Wrong? Solving the V'chol Maaminim Mystery

We’ve Been Singing It All Wrong? Solving the V'chol Maaminim Mystery

2025-09-1901:07:48

The Saga of Shul Shmoozing: A Historical Look at Talking in Shul Across the Centuries

The Saga of Shul Shmoozing: A Historical Look at Talking in Shul Across the Centuries

2025-09-1101:00:30

The Cantonist Crisis

The Cantonist Crisis

2025-08-2201:23:33

The Four Halls That Never Were: A Critical Look at Yosifun’s Design of the Beis Hamikdash

The Four Halls That Never Were: A Critical Look at Yosifun’s Design of the Beis Hamikdash

2025-07-3001:05:49

The Draft Dilemma: The Chilling Reality of Jews Deciding Who Gets Drafted

The Draft Dilemma: The Chilling Reality of Jews Deciding Who Gets Drafted

2025-07-0401:19:35

The Dilemma of Handing Over One to Save Many

The Dilemma of Handing Over One to Save Many

2025-06-2001:09:11

The Rabbi Who Couldn’t Quit Gambling

The Rabbi Who Couldn’t Quit Gambling

2025-06-1001:07:00

Up High or Down Low? The Battle Over the Proper Trop for the Aseres Hadibros

Up High or Down Low? The Battle Over the Proper Trop for the Aseres Hadibros

2025-05-2801:13:40

The Great Semicha Controversy, Part II

The Great Semicha Controversy, Part II

2025-05-2001:14:55

The Great Semicha Controversy, 1538

The Great Semicha Controversy, 1538

2025-05-1301:13:58

The Doctored Talmud: Prague, 1728

The Doctored Talmud: Prague, 1728

2025-05-0601:21:14

The Marranos’ Secret Pesach

The Marranos’ Secret Pesach

2025-04-0201:11:26

The Machine Matzah Controversy

The Machine Matzah Controversy

2025-04-0201:19:20

The Story of the Alter Rebbe’s Script

The Story of the Alter Rebbe’s Script

2025-03-2601:19:49

Rambam, the Almohads, and the Secret Jews

Rambam, the Almohads, and the Secret Jews

2025-03-1301:09:08

Rambam to the Rescue: His Legendary Letter to Yemen

Rambam to the Rescue: His Legendary Letter to Yemen

2025-02-2801:03:30

The Regensburg Blood Libel

The Regensburg Blood Libel

2025-02-2101:06:22

The Scandalous Marriage, 1348

The Scandalous Marriage, 1348

2025-01-2401:04:41

Taxes and Tensions: The Story of Jewish Tax Disputes in Medieval Spain

Taxes and Tensions: The Story of Jewish Tax Disputes in Medieval Spain

2025-01-1701:06:26

Josephus

Josephus

2025-01-0901:05:23

00:00

00:00

x

The Dilemma of Handing Over One to Save Many

The Dilemma of Handing Over One to Save Many

Mordechai Dinerman