DiscoverThe Problem With...The Lies We Tell: The Good Immigrant, the Bad Narrative
The Lies We Tell: The Good Immigrant, the Bad Narrative

The Lies We Tell: The Good Immigrant, the Bad Narrative

Update: 2025-06-30
Share

Description

What makes an immigrant “good”? Is it a clean record? A full-time job? English without an accent? A smile that never complains?

In this episode of The Lies We Tell, I take you on a deep, personal, and political dive into one of the most dangerous myths in American life: the myth of the good immigrant.

We’ll trace the origins of this narrative—from Ellis Island to the modern border, from sitcoms to ICE raids—and expose how it's used to divide communities, justify injustice, and punish people just for surviving. I also share my story—how I came here as a kid, changed my name to fit in, served in the Marines, and still got profiled, doubted, and disrespected.

This isn’t just about immigrants. It’s about what happens when a country demands silence instead of justice.
So ask yourself: Could you survive the system you defend?
Because a lot of us already have. Barely.

🎧 Topics include:

  • The “good immigrant vs. bad immigrant” binary

  • Hollywood and news media narratives

  • The racism hiding behind “speak English”

  • Why respectability is a trap

  • What the immigration process actually costs

  • Personal reflection from my time in school, the Marines, and beyond

📌 Available now on Spotify, Apple, YouTube, and wherever you get your truth.

  • Center for Media and Social Impact – “Race and Immigration in Prime-Time TV”

  • Media Matters: “Fox News Obsession with Immigrant Crime” (2019)

  • University of Illinois Study (2019): Disproportionate Crime Coverage of Immigrants in Local News

  • PBS/FRONTLINE – Lost in Detention

  • “The Problem of the Good Immigrant” – The Atlantic, by Jia Tolentino

  • “Model Minority Myth” – Teaching Tolerance/SPLC

  • Erika Lee, The Making of Asian America

  • Yalidy Matos, Brown Threat: Identification and the Latino Threat Narrative in News Media

📚 SOURCES & REFERENCES🔍 Immigration Data & Policy📺 Media Analysis🌍 International Comparisons👁️ Personal Experience & Analysis

Comments 
In Channel
loading
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

The Lies We Tell: The Good Immigrant, the Bad Narrative

The Lies We Tell: The Good Immigrant, the Bad Narrative

Luis