Too Great Expectations

Too Great Expectations

Update: 2025-09-09
Share

Description

Don and Tom break down the overhyped expectations around recent market returns, referencing Jason Zweig’s analysis of 230 years of stock market data. They emphasize that spending and saving habits matter more than chasing 15% returns, and explain why realistic planning using a 3–6% real return assumption over 30-year rolling periods is more prudent. They also tackle questions about RMD strategies from Vanguard IRAs and the TSP’s F and G bond funds. The show ends with a tongue-in-cheek breakdown of NFL team valuations—yes, the Raiders rank surprisingly high.


0:04 Welcome, fatuousness defined, and realistic investing begins


0:52 Why you shouldn’t expect 15% returns forever—even if you got them


1:52 What Jason Zweig’s long-term data reveals about stock returns


2:51 Bogle warned us not to expect high returns—now what?


4:16 Spending and saving: more important than investing performance


5:08 Don’s “prepaid gains” analogy for future expectations


7:00 Real market returns since 1793—spoiler: they’re not 15%


8:58 Stocks might only beat inflation by 3%—and that’s still a win


9:45 Start saving early: waiting until 50 is a losing game


10:18 How to plan with lower expected returns (realistic scenarios)


11:56 Use expected return to guide your savings rate (3% = save 20%)


13:45 “You weren’t smart. You were lucky.” Now diversify.


15:31 Tom’s wife dreads football season—Don celebrates Chiefs loss


18:42 Listener RMD question: Which ETFs get tapped at Vanguard?


19:29 Bonds are back: fixed income up ~6% this year


20:24 Rebalancing vs. just selling: how to handle RMDs smartly


21:04 Raiders rank #4 in NFL valuations… but why?


24:36 Top NFL team values: Cowboys rule, Cardinals drool


27:27 Arizona sports: low attendance, low valuations


28:59 TSP question: F fund vs. G fund—what to use, when


30:25 Don favors the G fund for simplicity and ballast


31:45 Tom and Don disagree—F fund might return more, but…


32:26 Don’s vegetable-spiked coffee and Justin’s final TSP allocation


34:13 Listener Barbara has multiple annuities—Don and Tom say, “Yikes”


35:47 Why you probably talked to a salesperson, not a fiduciary


37:04 The free Appella consultation is steak-free and no-pressure

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Comments 
In Channel
A Few Good Qs

A Few Good Qs

2025-09-1222:15

Opportunities Overseas

Opportunities Overseas

2025-09-1126:40

Why So Mean?

Why So Mean?

2025-09-1042:31

Too Great Expectations

Too Great Expectations

2025-09-0941:08

Extended Child Care

Extended Child Care

2025-09-0827:05

Ready for a Few As

Ready for a Few As

2025-09-0516:44

Passive Bubble?

Passive Bubble?

2025-09-0442:27

September Nonsense

September Nonsense

2025-09-0342:46

Q&A&B(onds)

Q&A&B(onds)

2025-09-0225:22

Query Day

Query Day

2025-08-2920:57

Looking Back

Looking Back

2025-08-2829:00

Illiquid Alternatives

Illiquid Alternatives

2025-08-2742:09

Making Life Better

Making Life Better

2025-08-2640:19

Should Have Yielded

Should Have Yielded

2025-08-2527:34

Busy Day of Q&A

Busy Day of Q&A

2025-08-2226:34

Still Rising

Still Rising

2025-08-2132:16

Mind the Gap

Mind the Gap

2025-08-2042:03

Investing Trivia Time

Investing Trivia Time

2025-08-1942:57

Social Insecurity?

Social Insecurity?

2025-08-1827:04

More Money Answers

More Money Answers

2025-08-1523:57

loading
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Too Great Expectations

Too Great Expectations

Don McDonald