Discover
THE DAILY BLAST with Greg SargentTrump’s Angry, Unhinged Rants at Presser Show Things Will Get Very Bad
THE DAILY BLAST with Greg SargentTrump’s Angry, Unhinged Rants at Presser Show Things Will Get Very Bad
Trump’s Angry, Unhinged Rants at Presser Show Things Will Get Very Bad
Update: 2025-01-08
Share
Description
At a press conference on Tuesday, Donald Trump signaled that things are about to get very, very ugly. He wouldn’t rule out using military force to annex Greenland and the Panama Canal. He celebrated the idea that his threats to jail Mark Zuckerberg might have caused Zuckerberg to surrender to him. And Trump vowed to rename the Gulf of Mexico the Gulf of America. We talked to Jennifer Mercieca, a professor of rhetoric who writes about fascist tropes. She explains how Trump is attempting to acclimate Americans to expansionist nationalism and naked threats to jail people without cause to force them into line, and why that bodes so badly about what’s coming. Listen to this episode here.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Comments
Top Podcasts
The Best New Comedy Podcast Right Now – June 2024The Best News Podcast Right Now – June 2024The Best New Business Podcast Right Now – June 2024The Best New Sports Podcast Right Now – June 2024The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – June 2024The Best New Joe Rogan Experience Podcast Right Now – June 20The Best New Dan Bongino Show Podcast Right Now – June 20The Best New Mark Levin Podcast – June 2024
In Channel
Download from Google Play
Download from App Store
United States00:00
00:00
1.0x
0.5x
0.8x
1.0x
1.25x
1.5x
2.0x
3.0x
Sleep Timer
Off
End of Episode
5 Minutes
10 Minutes
15 Minutes
30 Minutes
45 Minutes
60 Minutes
120 Minutes
Transcript
00:00:00
[MUSIC]
00:00:02
With the election of Donald Trump, staying informed is more important than ever.
00:00:06
And we're thankful you've chosen to listen to the DSR Network.
00:00:10
Through the turbulent times ahead, we will continue to provide the insightful expert analysis on the issues that matter most around the world.
00:00:18
We ask that you consider becoming a member to support our effort to provide you the best content possible.
00:00:24
DSR members gain access to an ad-free listening experience, exclusive members only segments of our shows, our members only discord community and more.
00:00:34
Use Code Holiday 25 to get 50% off of your membership subscription at the DSR Network.com/by.
00:00:42
That's Code Holiday 25 at the DSR Network.com/by.
00:00:48
The DSR Network will evolve in exciting ways in the new year, and we hope you'll join us.
00:00:54
[MUSIC]
00:01:05
This is the Daily Blast from the New Republic, produced and presented by the DSR Network.
00:01:10
I'm your host, Greg Sargent.
00:01:12
[MUSIC]
00:01:20
On Tuesday, Donald Trump held a press conference.
00:01:23
At it, he wouldn't rule out using military force to annex Greenland and the Panama Canal.
00:01:29
Openly celebrated the idea that billionaire Mark Zuckerberg might have caved to his threats to put Zuckerberg in jail.
00:01:37
And said we're going to rename the Gulf of Mexico the Gulf of America.
00:01:41
Trump didn't appear to be kidding about that.
00:01:44
Today, we're going to look at these moments as efforts on Trump's part to make this kind of talk normal.
00:01:49
To acclimate Americans to things like malignant nationalist belligerence, and naked threats to jail people without cause to force them into line.
00:01:58
So we're chatting with Jennifer Merchia, a professor of rhetoric and communication at Texas A&M University, who writes about right wing and fascist rhetorical tropes and how they really work.
00:02:09
Good to have you back on, Jennifer.
00:02:10
>> Thank you so much for having me on.
00:02:13
>> So let's start with what Trump said about meta-CEO Mark Zuckerberg.
00:02:18
He just announced that meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram, will stop using third-party fact-checking.
00:02:24
And Zuckerberg actually repeated Trump's lies about this, saying fact-checking has proven to bias than has so distrust.
00:02:32
That's nonsense, but listen to this exchange between Trump and a reporter about Zuckerberg's decision.
00:02:38
>> If you think he's redirecting responding to the threat that you have made to him in the past, but probably, sure, probably.
00:02:44
Jen, over the summer, Trump floated the idea that Zuckerberg could spend the rest of his life in prison if Trump decided that his conduct during the 2024 election merited it.
00:02:53
So let's be clear, Trump is saying it's good that his threats to corruptly use law enforcement to silence dissent worked for him.
00:03:01
Your thoughts on that?
00:03:03
>> That's how authoritarian's keep power.
00:03:06
That's how they gain and keep power, and that's how they maintain a compliant media that doesn't says what they want it to do and say.
00:03:18
The first thing that an autocrat does, so someone like Mussolini taking power, someone like Hitler taking power, but not just them, all of them.
00:03:28
The first thing they do is they want to control the media.
00:03:31
These guys are worried about the bottom line.
00:03:34
More than they're worried about democracy, of course.
00:03:37
And they were never really in the platform business because they wanted to promote and protect democracy.
00:03:45
That was eulogistic covering for what they really wanted, which was money and power.
00:03:52
And so for them, it's not so hard to say, well, the money and power are easier to get if I capitulate to Trump.
00:04:02
So let's just make sure he knows that I'm doing it.
00:04:04
So let's just say for the moment, along the lines of kind of the anti-alarmist take, which I don't agree with, but let's just adopt it for the moment.
00:04:16
Let's say Trump has no actual intention of really putting Zuckerberg in jail for life.
00:04:22
It still seems to me that Trump is trying to get voters used to the idea that it's not only appropriate, but actually good for him and his supporters to threaten to imprison people who displease him in some way.
00:04:37
He's getting them acclimated to the idea that this is a legitimate and positive use of state power that this serves his ends and theirs, meaning his supporters.
00:04:48
So what degree is that kind of a common authoritarian rhetorical troll?
00:04:52
Yeah, it absolutely is.
00:04:54
And so the rhetorical figure is ad-backulum, which is threats of force or intimidation.
00:04:59
And it's, of course, a form of coercion.
00:05:04
All authoritarians use threats of force and intimidation.
00:05:11
They coerce others.
00:05:12
That's how they become powerful.
00:05:15
And you know that they do that because they're not Democrats, right?
00:05:19
Democrats don't do that.
00:05:20
Like small-d Democrats, the opposite of an authoritarian is someone who uses rhetoric, right?
00:05:28
Meaning that they use rhetoric to persuade.
00:05:31
Persuasion is an invitation to think like I do, I use good evidence, I try, you know, in the best way I know how to use good argumentation, all of that kind of stuff,
00:05:42
those skills.
00:05:42
That's what small-d Democrats do.
00:05:45
They're cognitively responsible leaders, meaning that they allow people to ask questions to hold them accountable.
00:05:52
Authoritarians, they don't do that.
00:05:55
They use propaganda, they use communication as a weapon, as a kind of force.
00:06:00
And they're not cognitively responsible, meaning they want to say, because I said so, and have that be the final answer.
00:06:09
They don't want to have to give good reasons.
00:06:11
They don't want to have to give good evidence.
00:06:14
They don't want to have a meeting of the minds, right?
00:06:17
It's not like that for them.
00:06:19
They just want you to say yes, sir.
00:06:21
And so, authoritarians use propaganda, they use coercion, they use language as coercion.
00:06:30
That's fundamental to what authoritarianism is, like that's its essential quality.
00:06:35
And is he trying to get his voters to see this as a good thing, a normal thing, something that serves their interests?
00:06:44
Yes, so here's the trick.
00:06:45
So his voters want that.
00:06:47
His voters want him to do that and show that.
00:06:50
His voters would not like it if any Democratic Party member politician did that, right?
00:06:56
They don't want the government to do that, but they want Donald Trump to do that.
00:07:00
And that's because that's what right-wing authoritarian personalities want.
00:07:06
They want a strong leader, they want someone who's going to come in and say, this is how it is.
00:07:11
And if you don't do it the way I want you to, that's it.
00:07:14
You go to jail or whatever.
00:07:16
There's another type of voter out there, maybe low propensity, non-white, young, economically anxious.
00:07:23
We've talked about this on the show before, but just repeating it in this context, maybe those voters didn't really listen to the authoritarian talk, don't really care much about it,
00:07:34
maybe they think, okay, I want someone who's strong, who will use his power to bring down prices or whatever.
00:07:43
To what degree is there an effort here to acclimate those people to this kind of tactic?
00:07:48
Yeah, that's a great observation.
00:07:51
So, so, right, so not everyone is a right-wing authoritarian who already wants this.
00:07:56
And so you could think of what Trump's doing as sort of moving the over, over 10 window, right, getting people used to something that would normally seem completely outrageous,
00:08:09
completely abnormal.
00:08:11
So, normalization is the process by which someone like Trump moves us from that is so bizarre.
00:08:19
I can't believe that it's shocking, it's outrageous to that's, of course, common sense, right?
00:08:27
And so that's, if you're thinking about that audience, then yes, that's what Trump's doing, is he's conditioning them to accept an even stronger sort of strong man persona than he's given them before.
00:08:42
So, Trump has also been threatening to annex Greenland and the Panama Canal.
00:08:48
At his presser or a reporter asks him if he'd rule out using military or economic coercion to secure those goals, listen to what happened then.
00:08:56
I can assure you, you're talking about Panama and Greenland.
00:09:00
No, I can't assure you on either of those two.
00:09:02
But I can say this, we need them for economic security.
00:09:07
The Panama Canal was built for our military.
00:09:10
There you are.
00:09:12
I'm not going to commit to that.
00:09:13
Now, it might, it might be that you'll have to do something.
00:09:16
Jen, note that he says we need those things for economic security.
00:09:21
That seems to justify pretty much anything like using force to seize whatever he says we quote unquote need.
00:09:26
What's your reaction to that?
00:09:29
Yeah, it was a very interesting exchange, especially because of that justification, well, we need it.
00:09:36
We need it for, and that was exactly what I was thinking was like we need it.
00:09:42
Why do we need it?
00:09:43
And then his follow-up sort of explanation that there's these ships that are going through these Chinese and Russian ships.
00:09:52
So, he's very concerned in this press conference about shipping routes and who controls them and he wants control of them.
00:10:03
And that seems to be the framework by which he is going to justify all kinds of, I mean,
00:10:13
illegal empire building.
00:10:15
I don't know how people are going to frame this, but really bizarre land grabs, it sounds like.
00:10:22
Right.
00:10:23
I want to try to highlight another aspect of that.
00:10:26
There's a certain type of observer out there who has tried to put a soft spin on Trump's nationalism, maybe by calling it populism or neo-populism as one New York Times writer put it or saying Trump is just speaking to people's desire for community and national social cohesion or to see national sovereignty strengthen that kind of thing.
00:10:48
But I think we're seeing Trump experimenting here with overtly malignant and expansionist nationalist rhetoric.
00:10:55
Is that a fair way to understand this and what's the real goal with that?
00:10:59
Yeah, I think of what Trump does is foe populism because he does use appeals to add populism.
00:11:10
He's constantly praising the wisdom of his followers and using them as a cudgel to justify his action, using them as a cudgel to attack his opponents.
00:11:23
He's constantly cultivating that relationship with his followers and praising them and talking about how they're the real Americans and how much he loves them and all of that.
00:11:33
But at the same time, he wouldn't really do anything for these folks.
00:11:37
He fleeces them of their money and uses them to fund his legal battles and things like that.
00:11:44
He doesn't really help them in the end.
00:11:47
I think of it as foe populism.
00:11:51
At the same time, I had a chance to go back and look at his inaugural address from last time.
00:11:59
What I saw there was that I was interested in how does he define the role of the presidency and what does he think the president's job is?
00:12:08
If you reread that speech, it's a dark speech, but what you'll see is that he thinks that the president has one job and that is to defend the nation's border.
00:12:19
That's what he had run on in 2016.
00:12:22
That is essentially what he ran on again in 2024.
00:12:27
There's a little bit of an element of that.
00:12:31
We need to defend our economic interests as if that's contained in the border.
00:12:37
But then the really interesting thing is that if he's really is talking about expansionism, then he's talking about redefining the American border and he's talking about including a lot of people in the United States of America that are not American,
00:12:52
which seems to be incredibly dissonant with everything he's ever said before about what the job of the president is and about the sanctity of the national border.
00:13:05
Okay, I want to play another clip.
00:13:06
Here Trump talks about renaming the Gulf of Mexico, the Gulf of America.
00:13:11
Listen to this.
00:13:12
So we're going to be changing the name of the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America, which has a beautiful ring that covers a lot of territory,
00:13:24
the Gulf of America.
00:13:25
What a beautiful name.
00:13:26
And it's appropriate.
00:13:28
It's appropriate.
00:13:29
And Mexico has to stop allowing millions of people to pour into our country.
00:13:35
They could stop them.
00:13:36
Jen, I don't know what to make of this.
00:13:39
Is he just saying to the world that he can do this because he can?
00:13:42
And if you don't like it, suck it.
00:13:44
What's the message to what's the message to his supporters supposed to be here?
00:13:48
I think that's definitely part of it.
00:13:52
You know, I imagine a Trump supporter who's like, wait a minute, I never thought of that.
00:13:59
Why is it called the Gulf of Mexico?
00:14:01
It should be called the Gulf of America.
00:14:03
Damn right, right?
00:14:04
Like, I can imagine there's a person out there who's like, yeah, why do we let them get away with that?
00:14:10
So a thing you might not remember from his first term is that they took Mount McKinley and they turned it into Denali.
00:14:19
And it's a thing that irritates him.
00:14:21
He's always bringing it up.
00:14:23
He wants to return it back to McKinley because for him, you know, it's the golden age of tariffs and whatnot, I think.
00:14:29
But and so this is kind of like that, right?
00:14:32
Like, he's going to use his Sharpie.
00:14:34
He's going to change the map and, you know, I'm not ego-involved.
00:14:38
It's not part of my, you know, self-concept if it's called the Gulf of Mexico or if it's called Gulf of America.
00:14:46
But Donald Trump seems to think that it matters, right?
00:14:49
To have the power to do these kinds of things.
00:14:52
He might be trolling us.
00:14:54
He might not be, he might be very serious about it, but to me, it doesn't matter, right?
00:15:00
Like, he'll go away and it'll be the Gulf of Mexico again.
00:15:03
It's fine.
00:15:04
You mean eventually he'll go away.
00:15:06
You know, to your point about the power of renaming, which, which he seems to sense here, the kind of power of the gesture.
00:15:15
He constantly talks about the renaming of confederately named forts as well.
00:15:21
And that's also a very similar impulse on his part, I think.
00:15:26
Yeah, absolutely.
00:15:27
You know, and it's one of those things that authoritarians and autocrats do, right?
00:15:32
Is that they try to create a cult of personality.
00:15:36
They do that through naming practices, so naming buildings, naming arenas, you know, town, schools, etc.
00:15:45
Donald Trump hasn't had a lot of that.
00:15:48
He hasn't been the benefactor of lots of new schools in streets.
00:15:53
Other, I think George Washington is the most named street in president in school for everything I bet.
00:15:58
He hasn't received a lot of that kind of stuff.
00:16:02
He would very much like to receive that kind of stuff, right?
00:16:05
And so he's trying to show the power that he has rhetorically, right?
00:16:11
To call something into being and to change its name and to make it his.
00:16:17
Yeah, it really is a gesture of power.
00:16:21
I want to highlight one of the thing about that clip.
00:16:23
Trump went on to say that Mexico isn't stopping migrants from traveling north to our southern border.
00:16:28
That's a lie.
00:16:29
In fact, due to Biden's diplomacy, Mexico has been doing a great deal to stop migrants.
00:16:34
And that's a key reason the more recent border apprehension numbers have gotten relatively low of late.
00:16:40
I've been calling this tactic the secondary lie or the subordinate lie.
00:16:46
After he says the outrageous thing about the Gulf of America, he slips in a big lie along with it.
00:16:52
And because the crazy thing gets all the attention, the other lie gets smuggled into our discourse without any scrutiny.
00:16:59
Is that a tactic that you've encountered before with the Thar Terrians and fascists?
00:17:03
How does this work?
00:17:05
Yeah, I think that's a really keen observation.
00:17:09
It's a fire hose of lies strategy, right?
00:17:12
Where it's lies all the way down.
00:17:14
Also called a gish gallop sometimes, where you're unable to fact check, you know, each and every point that is made.
00:17:23
And so it becomes very difficult to even say what happened because as you're saying what happened, you have to say, well this was a lie and this was a lie and this was a lie.
00:17:32
By the time you're at the end of that, you haven't really told much of a story.
00:17:36
So, Thar Terrians use just that fire hose model of lying to create unreality, right?
00:17:44
They create this sense that nothing is true.
00:17:47
Everything, you know, sort of create nihilism in a population.
00:17:51
Everything is a lie.
00:17:53
None of it matters.
00:17:54
Again, a Thar Terrians are cognitively irresponsible if, you know, if you have one take away from our conversation.
00:18:03
That means that they want the power, an unquestioned power, to say what is true, to say what is real, to say what is good,
00:18:14
what is bad, who is a friend, who is an enemy, and they don't want anyone to ever question them.
00:18:20
And so one strategy is to lie so much that people just give up.
00:18:26
I think that's clearly what's going on with him, whether he is very conscious of it or not.
00:18:33
Okay, final question.
00:18:34
You watched that press conference.
00:18:36
You saw all these things.
00:18:38
I think that suggests things are going to get pretty damn dark when he takes over.
00:18:42
What do you expect?
00:18:44
I expect it to be dark.
00:18:46
Yeah.
00:18:47
I believe him when he says he's going to be a dictator on day one.
00:18:50
I do not believe him when he says he's not going to be a dictator on day two, right?
00:18:55
I don't think in the world history, we've seen an example of someone assuming dictatorial power and then giving it up willingly.
00:19:03
That's never happened, especially not someone like Donald Trump, who is an unaccountable leader by nature who wants that power.
00:19:12
No, I mean, we've put a very dangerous person in office.
00:19:16
He plans to use his power in whatever way he can and however he wants, and I don't see how we're going to stop him from doing that.
00:19:27
Jen Merchia, I guess we're going to see soon enough how far he's going to get and how big a mistake voters made.
00:19:34
Thanks so much for coming on with us.
00:19:36
Thank you.
00:19:36
It's pleasure.
00:19:37
You've been listening to The Daily Blast with me, your host Greg Sargent.
00:19:44
The Daily Blast is a new Republic podcast and is produced by Riley Fessler on the DSR Network.
00:19:58
[BLANK_AUDIO]
00:20:07
