Abortion Is on the Ballot. Republicans Have a Plan.
Digest
This podcast delves into the complex landscape of abortion access in the United States, focusing on the challenges faced by abortion rights ballot initiatives in Florida and other states. The episode begins by exploring the Florida abortion ballot initiative, which faces a unique 60% threshold for passage. The podcast highlights the extensive efforts by the state government to thwart its success, including the use of taxpayer funds, misleading fiscal summaries, and voter intimidation tactics. The discussion then shifts to the broader context of abortion access in Florida, outlining the state's current landscape under the six-week ban. The podcast notes the shift from Florida being an abortion haven to a state where providers are now sending patients out of state for the procedure. The episode expands beyond Florida, examining the strategies employed by anti-abortion groups in other states to oppose abortion rights ballot initiatives. The podcast highlights the efforts in Missouri to remove the amendment from the ballot and the use of competing ballot measures in Nebraska to create voter confusion. Finally, the podcast reflects on the broader implications of the ongoing battles over abortion access, emphasizing the crucial role of state courts and the importance of direct democracy in allowing voters to express their will. It also critiques the tactics employed by Republican opponents, suggesting they are more focused on sowing confusion than engaging in substantive debate.
Outlines
Florida's Abortion Ballot Initiative: A Test of Democracy
This chapter examines the Florida abortion ballot initiative, highlighting the unique 60% threshold for passage and the extensive efforts by the state government to thwart its success. The chapter explores the use of taxpayer funds, misleading fiscal summaries, and voter intimidation tactics employed by Governor DeSantis' administration.
Florida's Abortion Access Under Six-Week Ban
This chapter provides context for the Florida ballot initiative by outlining the state's current abortion access landscape under the six-week ban. It discusses the shift from Florida being an abortion haven to a state where providers are now sending patients out of state for the procedure.
Challenges to Abortion Rights Ballot Initiatives Across the US
This chapter expands the discussion beyond Florida, examining the strategies employed by anti-abortion groups in other states to oppose abortion rights ballot initiatives. It highlights the efforts in Missouri to remove the amendment from the ballot and the use of competing ballot measures in Nebraska to create voter confusion.
The Role of Courts and Democracy in Abortion Access
This chapter reflects on the broader implications of the ongoing battles over abortion access, emphasizing the crucial role of state courts and the importance of direct democracy in allowing voters to express their will. It also critiques the tactics employed by Republican opponents, suggesting they are more focused on sowing confusion than engaging in substantive debate.
Keywords
Ballot Initiative
A process by which citizens can propose and vote on laws or constitutional amendments directly, bypassing the legislative process. It is a form of direct democracy that empowers citizens to have a greater say in shaping their state's laws.
Fiscal Summary
A document that estimates the financial impact of a proposed ballot initiative on the state's budget. In the context of abortion access, this document has been manipulated to present misleading information about the potential costs of legalizing abortion.
Voter Intimidation
Actions or threats designed to discourage or prevent individuals from voting or participating in the electoral process. In the case of the Florida abortion ballot initiative, this included sending election crimes officers to the homes of voters who had signed petitions.
Direct Democracy
A system of government where citizens have a direct say in making laws and decisions, often through mechanisms like ballot initiatives and referendums. It contrasts with representative democracy, where citizens elect representatives to make decisions on their behalf.
Supermajority
A requirement for a legislative vote to pass a bill or amendment that is higher than a simple majority. In Florida, ballot initiatives require a 60% supermajority to pass, making it more difficult to enact change through direct democracy.
Abortion Access
The ability of individuals to obtain safe and legal abortion services. This is a complex and contentious issue, with varying levels of access and restrictions across different states.
State Courts
Judicial bodies that have jurisdiction over legal matters within a specific state. In the context of abortion access, state courts play a crucial role in interpreting and enforcing state laws related to abortion.
Republican Opponents
Individuals or groups affiliated with the Republican Party who oppose abortion rights and seek to restrict access to abortion services.
Q&A
What are the unique challenges facing the Florida abortion ballot initiative?
The initiative faces a 60% threshold for passage, a high bar for any ballot measure. Additionally, the state government has actively sought to undermine its success through misleading fiscal summaries, voter intimidation tactics, and legal challenges.
How are anti-abortion groups attempting to influence the outcome of abortion ballot initiatives in other states?
In Missouri, they attempted to remove the amendment from the ballot altogether. In Nebraska, they are employing a strategy of creating voter confusion by placing competing ballot measures on the ballot, one supporting and one opposing abortion rights.
What are the broader implications of the ongoing battles over abortion access?
These battles highlight the crucial role of state courts in shaping abortion policy in the post-Roe era. They also underscore the importance of direct democracy in allowing voters to express their will on issues that are deeply divisive.
Show Notes
When put to the voters, abortion rights have been winning over stricter restrictions even in places like deeply red Kansas. But Florida Republicans are working hard to defeat a ballot measure that would roll back the state’s six-week abortion ban—and they might have found a formula to win.
Guest: Grace Panetta, political reporter at The 19th.
We want to hear from you! Submit your answers to our What Next listener survey at slate.com/WhatNextSurvey.
Want more What Next? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Table of contents
United States
