Case 251: The Caldwell Farmhouse Murders

Update: 2023-06-17

Description

*** Content warning: Child victim, animal cruelty ***

When single mother Nadja Medley met an older man named Mike Bullinger, she finally found happiness after a difficult few years. As well as being a fun, kind-hearted partner, Mike was a wonderful father figure to Nadja’s 14-year-old daughter Payton. In May 2017, the three of them moved from Ogden, Utah, to a farmhouse Mike had just bought in Caldwell, Idaho.

But when a woman by the name of Cheryl Baker arrived unannounced at the property one day, tragedy ensued.

---

Narration – Anonymous Host

Research & writing – Erin Munro

Creative direction – Milly Raso

Production and music – Mike Migas

Music – Andrew D.B. Joslyn

Sign up for Casefile Premium:

Apple Premium

Spotify Premium

Patreon

For all credits and sources, please visit casefilepodcast.com/case-251-the-caldwell-farmhouse-murders

Comments (3)

Saffron_DE

Really think about what she said. That is what Mike did. He lived his life the way he wanted. He didn't stop beating his first wife. He told the kids, "What happens in my house, stays in my house." He killed all three of them and left the animals to die because of his selfish needs. Being selfless and doing what IS right instead of what YOU want can be more fulfilling. Think about more than your little existence. Think about the effects of what you do to everything around you. Don't be like Mike

Sep 27th