Democracy Now! 2024-09-10 Tuesday
Digest
The episode begins with a discussion of the ongoing conflict in Gaza, highlighting the death of at least 40 Palestinians in an Israeli strike and the suspension of some arms exports to Israel by Britain. Tarek Ali, a Pakistani British historian, discusses the global divide regarding the Gaza conflict, criticizing the US's role in the conflict and emphasizing the influence of the White House, Pentagon, and State Department on Israel's actions. The conversation then shifts to Pakistan, where Imran Khan, the former prime minister, has been detained for over a year. Ali discusses the lack of pressure on Pakistan to release Khan and the influence of the Pakistani military in the country's politics. The discussion moves to Bangladesh, where supporters of the former prime minister, Sheikh Hasina, have claimed US involvement in the recent uprising. Ali dismisses this claim, arguing that the uprising was driven by students demanding democratic rights and freedoms. He emphasizes the continued influence of the military in Bangladesh's politics. Ali then discusses the political situation in France, where President Macron appointed a conservative prime minister despite the leftist parties winning the most votes in the parliamentary elections. He criticizes Macron's authoritarian approach and his failure to engage with the leftist parties. Ali discusses the growing strength of the extreme right and anti-immigrant parties across Europe, particularly in Germany and Britain. He attributes this trend to economic and social crises and the failure of mainstream politicians to address the concerns of the working and middle classes. The episode shifts focus to the Gaza death toll, which has officially surpassed 41,000. Ralph Nader, a consumer advocate and former presidential candidate, argues that the actual death toll is significantly higher, potentially reaching hundreds of thousands. He criticizes the US government's support for Israel and its denial of Israel's targeting of civilians. The episode features a reading of Frederick Douglass's powerful speech, "What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?" by the late actor James Earl Jones. The speech highlights the hypocrisy of celebrating independence while denying freedom and equality to enslaved people. Nader continues his discussion of the Gaza death toll undercount, providing evidence to support his claim that the true number is much higher. He also criticizes Israel's refusal to allow foreign press into Gaza and its targeting of journalists and UN relief workers. The episode concludes with a call to action, urging viewers to watch the upcoming debate between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris and to stay informed about the ongoing conflict in Gaza.
Outlines
Global Conflict and Political Tensions
The episode begins with a discussion of the ongoing conflict in Gaza, highlighting the death of at least 40 Palestinians in an Israeli strike and the suspension of some arms exports to Israel by Britain. Tarek Ali, a Pakistani British historian, discusses the global divide regarding the Gaza conflict, criticizing the US's role in the conflict and emphasizing the influence of the White House, Pentagon, and State Department on Israel's actions.
Political Situations in Pakistan and Bangladesh
The conversation then shifts to Pakistan, where Imran Khan, the former prime minister, has been detained for over a year. Ali discusses the lack of pressure on Pakistan to release Khan and the influence of the Pakistani military in the country's politics. The discussion moves to Bangladesh, where supporters of the former prime minister, Sheikh Hasina, have claimed US involvement in the recent uprising. Ali dismisses this claim, arguing that the uprising was driven by students demanding democratic rights and freedoms. He emphasizes the continued influence of the military in Bangladesh's politics.
Political Situation in France and the Rise of the Extreme Right
Ali discusses the political situation in France, where President Macron appointed a conservative prime minister despite the leftist parties winning the most votes in the parliamentary elections. He criticizes Macron's authoritarian approach and his failure to engage with the leftist parties. Ali discusses the growing strength of the extreme right and anti-immigrant parties across Europe, particularly in Germany and Britain. He attributes this trend to economic and social crises and the failure of mainstream politicians to address the concerns of the working and middle classes.
The Gaza Death Toll and the Undercount
The episode shifts focus to the Gaza death toll, which has officially surpassed 41,000. Ralph Nader, a consumer advocate and former presidential candidate, argues that the actual death toll is significantly higher, potentially reaching hundreds of thousands. He criticizes the US government's support for Israel and its denial of Israel's targeting of civilians.
Frederick Douglass's Speech on the Fourth of July
The episode features a reading of Frederick Douglass's powerful speech, "What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?" by the late actor James Earl Jones. The speech highlights the hypocrisy of celebrating independence while denying freedom and equality to enslaved people.
Continued Discussion of the Gaza Death Toll Undercount
Nader continues his discussion of the Gaza death toll undercount, providing evidence to support his claim that the true number is much higher. He also criticizes Israel's refusal to allow foreign press into Gaza and its targeting of journalists and UN relief workers.
Conclusion and Call to Action
The episode concludes with a call to action, urging viewers to watch the upcoming debate between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris and to stay informed about the ongoing conflict in Gaza.
Keywords
Gaza Death Toll Undercount
The discrepancy between the official death toll in Gaza and the estimated actual number of casualties, which is believed to be significantly higher due to indirect deaths caused by the war and the lack of access to essential services.
Global Divide
The growing division between those who oppose their governments' unconditional support for Israel and those who support the ongoing conflict in Gaza.
Political Situation in Pakistan
The detention of former Prime Minister Imran Khan and the influence of the Pakistani military in the country's politics.
Political Situation in Bangladesh
The recent uprising in Bangladesh and the continued influence of the military in the country's politics.
Political Situation in France
President Macron's authoritarian approach to politics, his failure to engage with the leftist parties, and the growing influence of the far right.
Rise of the Extreme Right
The growing strength of the extreme right and anti-immigrant parties across Europe, attributed to economic and social crises and the failure of mainstream politicians to address the concerns of the working and middle classes.
Frederick Douglass's Speech
A powerful speech by Frederick Douglass that highlights the hypocrisy of celebrating independence while denying freedom and equality to enslaved people.
Q&A
What is the main argument made by Ralph Nader regarding the Gaza death toll?
Nader argues that the official death toll in Gaza is a significant undercount, potentially reaching hundreds of thousands due to indirect deaths caused by the war and the lack of access to essential services. He believes that the true number is being suppressed for political reasons.
How does Tarek Ali describe the global divide regarding the Gaza conflict?
Ali describes a growing divide between those who oppose their governments' unconditional support for Israel and those who support the ongoing conflict. He highlights the opposition of many to the actions of their governments, particularly in the US and Europe.
What is the significance of Frederick Douglass's speech, "What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?"
Douglass's speech exposes the hypocrisy of celebrating independence while denying freedom and equality to enslaved people. It highlights the ongoing struggle for justice and equality in the face of systemic oppression.
What are some of the key concerns raised by Tarek Ali about the political situation in France?
Ali criticizes President Macron's authoritarian approach to politics, his failure to engage with the leftist parties that won the most votes in the parliamentary elections, and his appointment of a conservative prime minister. He also expresses concern about the growing influence of the far right in France.
How does Tarek Ali explain the rise of the extreme right and anti-immigrant sentiment in Europe?
Ali attributes this trend to economic and social crises, the failure of mainstream politicians to address the concerns of the working and middle classes, and the use of propaganda that demonizes immigrants as a threat to national identity or security.
Show Notes
Headlines for September 10, 2024; Tariq Ali on U.S. & U.K. Arming Israel’s War on Gaza, Pakistan Protests & Macron’s Embrace of the Right; RIP James Earl Jones: Watch Him Read Frederick Douglass’s “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?”; “A Horrifying Undercount”: Ralph Nader Says True Gaza Death Toll Could Be Many Times Higher