DiscoverThe Stay-at-Homeschooling Mom PodcastGetting a Handle on Homeschool Discipline
Getting a Handle on Homeschool Discipline

Getting a Handle on Homeschool Discipline

Update: 2025-08-06
Share

Description

Some homeschool moms on social media are miserable.  Their kids are out of control, and it's often described as a typical day. 

Well, it wasn't our typical day – and it doesn't have to be yours either. Nothing can derail home education faster than out-of-control kids.

Today, on The Stay-at-Homeschooling Mom Podcast, Mary Ellen and Ginny discuss why this is happening and share the ways to fix it. 

Show Notes:

Out-of-control kids are not unique to homeschooling families.  A trip to the park, the library, or a family restaurant will convince you that poorly behaved children are epidemic.  Many parents have convinced themselves that brattiness is just a normal stage of growing up, like cutting teeth -- it is not.  In countries all over the world, children are obedient, respectful, hardworking, and even sacrificial.

Why have we lost control?  A few ideas:

  • Americans are generally pretty well off.  
  • In movies and TV, parents, especially dads, are often portrayed as buffoons. 
  • Childcare professionals, the so-called experts, give terrible advice.

So, who SHOULD we follow for parenting advice?  

Catholics should follow just three "pages" when it comes to raising their children:  

  • Sacred Scripture
  • Our Holy Traditions
  • The Magisterium or teaching authority of the church.

The 4th Commandment is NOT a suggestion.  

We are required to teach our children to honor and obey us in everything that is not sinful.

The simplest path to well-behaved kids is to establish your authority right from the start.  As soon as they can understand you, probably about 1 ½ years

Rule #1: Clear, easy-to-understand rules.  

  • BEFORE we leave our bedroom in the morning, we stow dirty clothes and make our beds.  
  • When we get up from the table, we clear our places. 
  • We always say please and thank you.  

Rule #2: Don't whine or beg your children to be good.  

  • Express your expectations clearly and leave no room for doubt. 
  • If they don't listen, give a clear and immediate consequence.  

Rule #3: Do not give delayed consequences.

  • "No TV for you tonight is ineffective."  The kid will never remember, nor will you.  
  • You don't have to yell or scream – calm and confident works best.  
  • You just have to persevere. 

Rule #4: Do not argue with your kids:  

  • You will never win!   
  • Expect obedience and walk away from an obstinate child.  
  • Do not engage. 

Rule #5: A simple, sensible schedule and a check-off list for responsibilities.

Set a regular time and post it on the fridge or a whiteboard:

  • Schoolwork
  • Chores
  • Instrumental practice, or whatever
  • Too strict? It's just the opposite.  There's ultimately less stress when children know what is expected of them.

Tune in in two weeks for part 2 of our discipline series.  

Homeschooling Resources

Seton Home Study School

Seton Testing Services

Comments 
loading
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Getting a Handle on Homeschool Discipline

Getting a Handle on Homeschool Discipline

Seton Home Study School