P&C or HR?

P&C or HR?

Update: 2025-12-03
Share

Description

This episode examines how hype often outpaces reality in business, using WeWork, Bodega Boxes, and Theranos as examples of ideas that generated enormous buzz but couldn’t deliver on their promises, then applies Gartner’s hype cycle to show how new concepts move from excitement to disappointment before settling into their true value. You use this lens to question whether the shift from “HR” to “People & Culture” represents real change or just a rebrand, concluding that the answer varies by organisation and may be more hype than substance, especially since the underlying administrative and compliance work hasn’t disappeared. Ultimately, you argue that if workplaces want genuine improvement, they must change their practices—not just their job titles.


Comments 
In Channel
Magic words

Magic words

2025-12-2312:44

Flawed mentors

Flawed mentors

2025-12-0912:58

P&C or HR?

P&C or HR?

2025-12-0314:33

Positive fish

Positive fish

2025-11-1111:55

Strategising up

Strategising up

2025-10-2712:38

Rethinking Risk

Rethinking Risk

2025-10-1312:52

Low hanging fruit

Low hanging fruit

2025-10-0113:34

Home again

Home again

2025-09-2212:41

Whitney: the greatest

Whitney: the greatest

2025-08-3111:24

Can't live there

Can't live there

2025-08-2412:40

Best fit or practice?

Best fit or practice?

2025-08-2111:34

loading
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

P&C or HR?

P&C or HR?

Dr Damian Treanor, Pragmatic HRM