The Sisterhood is back with their very first book club pick… and let’s just say, it wasn’t a hit for everyone (only two sisters actually finished it). Join us as we dive into all things tropes—the ones we adore, the ones we can’t stand, and the ones that fall somewhere in between.

Sam spills on a new duology she’s started, Kate raves about finishing Heavenly Bodies (and is already begging for the next one), and Chesleigh isn’t so sure Sam will ever actually pick it up. We also reveal our next book club pick—When the Moon Hatched by Sarah A. Parker—so grab your copy and read along with us!

Along the way, you’ll hear about Chesleigh’s childhood nickname (which she still isn’t thrilled about, though Sam insists on reviving it), and of course, some heated Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah banter.

Don’t forget to share your favorite enemies-to-lovers book recs with the Sisterhood—we’re always looking for our next obsession!