Why Shein and Temu Are At War
Digest
This podcast delves into the world of She-in, a Chinese fast-fashion retailer that has become a global phenomenon. The episode begins by introducing She-in's unique business model, which relies on ultra-fast fashion, a strategy that involves producing and delivering trendy items quickly and cheaply. The podcast highlights the company's rapid growth and its controversial practices, including its reliance on a Chinese supply chain, accusations of labor violations, and design theft. The episode then explores She-in's pricing strategy, which leverages the "Diminimus Exception" to import goods duty-free from China. This strategy allows She-in to offer incredibly low prices, but it also raises concerns about labor practices and ethical sourcing. The podcast examines reports of child labor, forced labor in the Xinjiang region, and allegations of excessive working hours and wage theft. The episode also discusses She-in's plans to go public in the US and the challenges it faces. The company's IPO prospects are uncertain, given the current geopolitical climate and the scrutiny it faces. The podcast explores the potential implications of She-in going public, including increased transparency into its finances and operations. The episode concludes by examining the broader implications of fast fashion and the ethical concerns surrounding the industry. The podcast explores the question of whether consumers should hold all fast fashion retailers to a higher standard, regardless of their ties to China.
Outlines
She-in: The Rise of a Fast-Fashion Giant
This episode introduces She-in, a retail giant valued at over $60 billion, and discusses its unique business model and rapid growth. The episode explores the company's controversial practices, including its ultra-fast fashion approach, its reliance on a Chinese supply chain, and accusations of labor violations and design theft.
She-in's Business Model and Ultra-Fast Fashion
This episode delves into She-in's ultra-fast fashion model, highlighting its ability to produce and deliver trendy items quickly and cheaply. The episode compares She-in to other fast fashion retailers like Zara and H&M, emphasizing its speed and low prices.
She-in's Operations and Ethical Concerns
This episode examines She-in's pricing strategy, highlighting its reliance on a Chinese supply chain and the "Diminimus Exception" to import goods duty-free. The episode discusses the implications of this model for labor practices and ethical sourcing, exploring reports of child labor, forced labor in the Xinjiang region, and allegations of excessive working hours and wage theft.
She-in's Future and the Broader Implications of Fast Fashion
This episode discusses She-in's plans to go public in the US and the challenges it faces. The episode explores the skepticism surrounding Chinese tech companies in the US, the company's PR efforts, and the potential impact of its controversial practices on its IPO prospects. The episode also discusses the broader implications of fast fashion and the ethical concerns surrounding the industry.
Keywords
Ultra-fast fashion
A business model in the fashion industry characterized by rapid production and delivery of trendy items at low prices, often relying on low-cost labor and materials.
Diminimus Exception
A US customs rule that allows packages valued under $800 to enter the country duty-free when shipped to individuals, often used by companies like She-in to import goods directly from China.
Forced labor
A form of labor exploitation where individuals are coerced or compelled to work against their will, often under harsh conditions and without fair compensation.
Design theft
The unauthorized copying or appropriation of original designs, often involving the reproduction and sale of similar products without permission from the original designer.
IPO (Initial Public Offering)
The process of a private company becoming publicly traded by issuing shares of stock to the public, allowing investors to purchase ownership in the company.
Supply chain transparency
The ability to track and understand the origins and processes involved in the production and distribution of goods, including labor practices, environmental impact, and ethical sourcing.
Race to the bottom
A competitive dynamic where companies lower prices and standards to gain market share, often leading to exploitation of workers and environmental degradation.
Geopolitical tensions
The complex and often strained relationships between countries, including economic, political, and social factors that can influence business decisions and trade relations.
Q&A
What is She-in's business model and how does it differ from other fast fashion retailers?
She-in operates on an ultra-fast fashion model, producing and delivering trendy items quickly and cheaply. This differs from other fast fashion retailers like Zara and H&M by being even faster and offering even lower prices.
How does She-in manage to offer such low prices?
She-in relies on a Chinese supply chain, utilizing low-cost labor and manufacturing. It also benefits from the "Diminimus Exception," which allows packages under $800 to enter the US duty-free, enabling direct-to-consumer shipping from China.
What are the ethical concerns surrounding She-in's operations?
She-in faces accusations of child labor, forced labor in the Xinjiang region, and excessive working hours and wage theft in its factories. There are also concerns about its sourcing of materials and the environmental impact of its fast fashion model.
What are the implications of She-in's IPO plans?
She-in's IPO could lead to increased transparency into its finances and operations, but it also faces skepticism due to its ties to China and its controversial practices. The company's IPO prospects are uncertain, given the current geopolitical climate and the scrutiny it faces.
How are the lawsuits between She-in and Temu impacting the companies?
The lawsuits between She-in and Temu highlight the competitive nature of the ultra-cheap fashion market and the accusations of unfair business practices. These legal battles could impact both companies' financial performance and their future in the US market.
What are the broader implications of fast fashion for consumers and society?
Fast fashion raises ethical concerns about labor practices, environmental impact, and the sustainability of the industry. Consumers are faced with trade-offs between affordability and ethical sourcing, and the question of whether to hold all fast fashion retailers to a higher standard remains a complex issue.
Show Notes
Can fast-fashion giant Shein go public while fending off accusations of bad labor practices, the US government, and a back-and-forth war with newcomer Temu?
Guest: Mia Sato, platforms and communities reporter at the Verge.
Want more What Next? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Table of contents
United States
