A Mother Accused
1Digest
This episode of Killer Psyche delves into the case of Paulette Welch, a mother accused of murdering her 19-month-old son, Stockton. The episode explores the events leading up to Stockton's death, the medical evidence, and the conflicting perspectives of the doctors and Paulette's family. The defense argues that Stockton's death was an accident, likely caused by a previous head injury he sustained in a fall, challenging the validity of shaken baby syndrome. The episode also delves into the controversy surrounding shaken baby syndrome, with experts questioning its validity and the potential for misdiagnosis. The episode then shifts to the case of Mary Weaver, another woman accused of shaking a baby to death, exploring the role of Dr. Thomas Bennett, the medical examiner who diagnosed shaken baby syndrome in Mary's case, and the subsequent challenges she faced in proving her innocence. The episode returns to Paulette's case, focusing on the plea bargain offered to her by the prosecution. The episode explores the complexities of the plea bargain, Paulette's decision to accept it, and the reactions of those involved in the case. The episode concludes with a reflection on the outcome of Paulette's case, highlighting the lingering questions and the impact of the case on those involved. The episode also briefly mentions the ongoing legal battles faced by other individuals accused of shaken baby syndrome.
Outlines
The Case of Paulette Welch
This episode explores the case of Paulette Welch, a mother accused of murdering her 19-month-old son, Stockton. The episode examines the events leading up to Stockton's death, the medical evidence, and the conflicting perspectives of the doctors and Paulette's family.
The Defense and the Controversy
The episode focuses on the defense's strategy in Paulette's murder trial, highlighting the support she receives from her community and the challenges they face in raising funds for her legal defense. The episode also delves into the controversy surrounding shaken baby syndrome, with experts questioning its validity and the potential for misdiagnosis.
Shaken Baby Syndrome and Mary Weaver's Case
The episode shifts to the case of Mary Weaver, another woman accused of shaking a baby to death. The episode explores the role of Dr. Thomas Bennett, the medical examiner who diagnosed shaken baby syndrome in Mary's case, and the subsequent challenges she faced in proving her innocence.
Paulette's Plea Bargain and the Outcome
The episode returns to Paulette's case, focusing on the plea bargain offered to her by the prosecution. The episode explores the complexities of the plea bargain, Paulette's decision to accept it, and the reactions of those involved in the case.
The Impact of the Case
The episode concludes with a reflection on the outcome of Paulette's case, highlighting the lingering questions and the impact of the case on those involved. The episode also briefly mentions the ongoing legal battles faced by other individuals accused of shaken baby syndrome.
Keywords
Shaken Baby Syndrome
A medical diagnosis that refers to injuries sustained by a baby due to violent shaking. It can cause severe brain damage, blindness, and even death. The diagnosis is controversial, with some experts questioning its validity and potential for misdiagnosis.
Shaken Baby Syndrome Controversy
The debate surrounding the diagnosis of shaken baby syndrome, with some experts arguing that it is overdiagnosed and that other causes of injury are often overlooked. The controversy has led to wrongful convictions and raised concerns about the reliability of medical evidence in child abuse cases.
Plea Bargain
An agreement between the prosecution and the defendant in a criminal case, where the defendant pleads guilty to a lesser charge in exchange for a reduced sentence or other concessions. Plea bargains are often used to avoid the time and expense of a trial, but they can also raise ethical concerns about the potential for innocent people to plead guilty to avoid a harsher sentence.
Child Abuse
Any form of physical, emotional, or sexual abuse of a child. Child Abuse can have devastating consequences for children, including physical injury, emotional trauma, and long-term health problems. It is a serious crime that is often difficult to detect and prosecute.
Medical Malpractice
Negligence by a medical professional that results in harm to a patient. Medical malpractice can take many forms, including misdiagnosis, improper treatment, and failure to obtain informed consent. It can have serious consequences for patients, including physical injury, emotional distress, and financial hardship.
Forensic Pathology
A branch of pathology that focuses on the investigation of death and injury. Forensic pathologists examine bodies, perform autopsies, and analyze evidence to determine the cause of death and the circumstances surrounding it. Their findings are often used in criminal investigations and legal proceedings.
Justice
The fair and impartial administration of the law. Justice is a fundamental principle of a just society, ensuring that all individuals are treated equally under the law and that those who commit crimes are held accountable for their actions. It is a complex concept that is often debated and contested, with different perspectives on what constitutes a just outcome in a particular case.
Q&A
What is the main argument presented by the defense in Paulette Welch's case?
The defense argues that Stockton's death was an accident, likely caused by a previous head injury he sustained in a fall. They challenge the validity of shaken baby syndrome and argue that the doctors rushed to judgment.
What is the controversy surrounding shaken baby syndrome?
Some experts question the validity of shaken baby syndrome, arguing that it is overdiagnosed and that other causes of injury are often overlooked. This controversy has led to wrongful convictions and raised concerns about the reliability of medical evidence in child abuse cases.
Why did Paulette Welch plead guilty to the lesser charge of injuring a child?
Paulette pleaded guilty to avoid the risk of a trial and a possible conviction for murder, which could have resulted in a life sentence. She felt that this was the only way to guarantee she would be able to raise her daughter, Shaylin.
What is the impact of the case on the community and those involved?
The community is divided on the outcome of the case, with some feeling that justice was served and others believing that Paulette was wrongly convicted. The case has had a profound impact on the Welches, who are still struggling to cope with the loss of their son and the challenges they faced during the legal proceedings.
Show Notes
On May 1, 1999, the adopted son of Paulette and Kelly Welch died at their home in Idaho Falls, ID. Paulette Welch was charged with first-degree murder and took a plea bargain requiring a guilty plea to the lesser charge of injuring a child. Kelly was never charged. This report also includes the cases of Mary Weaver and Denise Rhode, both of whom were charged with causing a child’s death by shaking. Weaver was eventually acquitted and Rhode was convicted of first degree murder and child endangerment. Rhode remains in prison. "48 Hours" correspondents Susan Spencer and Richard Schlesinger report. This classic "48 Hours" episode last aired on 9/7/2001. Watch all-new episodes of “48 Hours” on Saturdays, and stream on demand on Paramount+.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Table of contents
United States
DO NOT interview a mother that has lost a small child. If she's crying, you can not understand a word she's saying and there is really no reason to do an interview, why bring up the trauma over and over again. Guilty or not, (we weren't there and have no idea what exactly happened) Do the interview well after the incident or by reading her response.