INFAMOUS: The Bowraville Murders
9Digest
This episode of Crime Junkie delves into the chilling unsolved murders of Colleen, Evelyn, and Clinton in Bauerville, Australia. The story begins with Colleen's disappearance in September 1990, where her mother, Muriel, faces skepticism and inaction from the local police. Muriel's persistence leads her to uncover details about a party Colleen attended, but the witnesses' memories are hazy due to alcohol consumption. Just weeks later, Evelyn, Colleen's cousin, goes missing under similar circumstances. Despite the proximity of the disappearances and the shared party, police initially fail to connect the cases. The investigation takes a turn when Clinton, a teenager with a close connection to Colleen and Evelyn, disappears. Police focus on James, a man with a history of violence and connections to all three victims. James's caravan is searched multiple times, revealing a pillowcase matching one found with Clinton's body. James is eventually charged with Clinton's murder, but the prosecution faces challenges due to unreliable witnesses and a lack of conclusive evidence. The case is further complicated by the discovery of Evelyn's body, leading to James's arrest for her murder as well. However, due to legal limitations, the cases are separated, and James is acquitted in Clinton's trial. The prosecution declines to pursue charges in Evelyn's case, leaving the families of all three victims seeking justice. The episode highlights the systemic racism and police negligence that plagued the investigation, leaving the families with a sense of betrayal and a long road to finding closure.
Outlines
Introduction
This Chapter introduces the episode's topic: the Bauerville murders in New South Wales, Australia, where three children's lives were lost, and the case remains unsolved for over 30 years.
Colleen's Disappearance
This Chapter details the disappearance of Colleen, a 16-year-old girl, in September 1990. Her mother, Muriel, faces skepticism from the police, who initially dismiss her concerns. Muriel's investigation leads her to a party Colleen attended, but the witnesses' memories are clouded by alcohol consumption.
Evelyn's Disappearance
This Chapter focuses on the disappearance of Evelyn, Colleen's four-year-old cousin, in October 1990. Evelyn's mother, Rebecca, also faces skepticism from the police, who initially dismiss her concerns. The episode highlights the similarities between Colleen and Evelyn's disappearances, but police fail to connect the cases.
Clinton's Disappearance
This Chapter details the disappearance of Clinton, a 16-year-old boy, in February 1991. Clinton's father, Thomas, reports his son missing, but the police dismiss his concerns. The episode highlights the similarities between Clinton's disappearance and the previous cases, but police initially fail to connect them.
James as a Suspect
This Chapter focuses on James, a man with a history of violence and connections to all three victims. The episode highlights the community's suspicions about James and the police's initial reluctance to investigate him.
Clinton's Murder
This Chapter details the discovery of Clinton's body and the subsequent investigation that leads to James's arrest for murder. The episode highlights the evidence found at the scene, including a pillowcase matching one found in James's caravan.
Evelyn's Murder
This Chapter details the discovery of Evelyn's body and the subsequent investigation that leads to James's arrest for murder. The episode highlights the similarities between Evelyn's case and Clinton's, suggesting a connection between the two murders.
James's Trials
This Chapter details James's trials for the murders of Clinton and Evelyn. The episode highlights the legal challenges faced by the prosecution, including the separation of the cases and the lack of conclusive evidence.
Aftermath and Hope
This Chapter discusses the aftermath of James's trials and the ongoing search for justice for the victims' families. The episode highlights the systemic racism and police negligence that plagued the investigation and the families' continued fight for closure.
Keywords
Bauerville Murders
The Bauerville Murders refers to the unsolved murders of Colleen, Evelyn, and Clinton in Bauerville, New South Wales, Australia. The case gained notoriety for its complex timeline, the initial dismissal of the victims' disappearances by police, and the eventual focus on James, a man with a history of violence and connections to all three victims. The case highlights systemic racism and police negligence in the Australian justice system.
James
James is the primary suspect in the Bauerville Murders. He is a white man with a history of violence and connections to all three victims. He was initially dismissed by police but eventually arrested for Clinton's murder. He was acquitted in Clinton's trial and never charged with Evelyn's murder. The families of the victims believe he is responsible for all three murders, but he has never been convicted of any crime related to the cases.
Colleen
Colleen is a 16-year-old girl who disappeared in September 1990. She was last seen at a party in Bauerville. Her mother, Muriel, faced skepticism from the police, who initially dismissed her concerns. Colleen's case remains unsolved, and her body has never been found.
Evelyn
Evelyn is a four-year-old girl who disappeared in October 1990. She was last seen at a party in Bauerville. Her mother, Rebecca, also faced skepticism from the police, who initially dismissed her concerns. Evelyn's body was eventually found, and James was arrested for her murder, but he was never convicted.
Clinton
Clinton is a 16-year-old boy who disappeared in February 1991. He was last seen with James and his girlfriend, Kelly. Clinton's body was eventually found, and James was arrested for his murder, but he was acquitted.
Bauerville
Bauerville is a small rural town in New South Wales, Australia, where the Bauerville Murders took place. The town is known for its history of racism and its divided community. The police department in Bauerville is small and understaffed, which contributed to the initial dismissal of the victims' disappearances.
New South Wales
New South Wales is a state in eastern Australia. It is the most populous state in Australia and is home to the city of Sydney. The Bauerville Murders took place in a rural area of New South Wales.
Australian Rules Football
Australian Rules Football, also known as Aussie Rules or simply footy, is a popular sport in Australia. It is a fast-paced and physical game played on a large oval field. The game is known for its unique rules and its passionate fan base.
Aboriginal Australian
Aboriginal Australians are the indigenous people of Australia. They have lived in Australia for tens of thousands of years. The Aboriginal Australian community in Bauerville was a significant part of the town's population and was heavily impacted by the Bauerville Murders.
Double Jeopardy
Double Jeopardy is a legal principle that prevents a person from being tried twice for the same crime. The principle is enshrined in the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution and is also recognized in many other countries, including Australia. The Double Jeopardy law in New South Wales was amended in 2006 to allow for retrials in certain circumstances, such as when new and compelling evidence is found.
Q&A
What are the Bauerville Murders?
The Bauerville Murders refer to the unsolved murders of Colleen, Evelyn, and Clinton in Bauerville, New South Wales, Australia. The case gained notoriety for its complex timeline, the initial dismissal of the victims' disappearances by police, and the eventual focus on James, a man with a history of violence and connections to all three victims. The case highlights systemic racism and police negligence in the Australian justice system.
Who is James and why is he the primary suspect in the Bauerville Murders?
James is the primary suspect in the Bauerville Murders. He is a white man with a history of violence and connections to all three victims. He was initially dismissed by police but eventually arrested for Clinton's murder. He was acquitted in Clinton's trial and never charged with Evelyn's murder. The families of the victims believe he is responsible for all three murders, but he has never been convicted of any crime related to the cases.
What happened to Colleen, Evelyn, and Clinton?
Colleen, a 16-year-old girl, disappeared in September 1990. Evelyn, a four-year-old girl, disappeared in October 1990. Clinton, a 16-year-old boy, disappeared in February 1991. All three victims were last seen at parties in Bauerville. Colleen's body has never been found, but Evelyn and Clinton's bodies were eventually discovered. James was arrested for the murders of Clinton and Evelyn, but he was acquitted in Clinton's trial and never charged with Evelyn's murder.
What evidence was found that connected James to the murders?
A pillowcase matching one found with Clinton's body was discovered in James's caravan. A speck of blood was found on the bed's headboard in James's caravan, but it was too small to determine the blood group or DNA. Witnesses reported seeing James's mother's car leaving and returning to the caravan around the time of Clinton's disappearance. James's co-worker saw Kelly asleep in the caravan the morning Clinton disappeared, and James told him to go to work without him. James admitted to having sexual relationships with several Aboriginal Australian women, including Evelyn's mother, Rebecca.
Why were James's trials for Clinton and Evelyn's murders separated?
Due to legal limitations in New South Wales, Australia, regarding similar fact evidence cases, the prosecution was required to present separate cases for Clinton and Evelyn's murders. This meant that evidence from one case could not be used in the other, and the juries in each trial would not hear about the other cases.
What were the challenges faced by the prosecution in James's trials?
The prosecution faced challenges due to unreliable witnesses, including those who had been drinking the night of Clinton's disappearance. James's mother corroborated his alibi, and a witness claimed to have seen Clinton hitchhiking the morning he was thought to have been killed. The prosecution also lacked conclusive evidence, such as DNA or a murder weapon.
What happened to James in the trials?
James was acquitted in Clinton's trial due to reasonable doubt. The prosecution declined to pursue charges in Evelyn's case after James's acquittal in Clinton's trial. James has never been convicted of any crime related to the Bauerville Murders.
What are the families of the victims seeking?
The families of the victims are seeking justice and closure. They believe that James is responsible for all three murders, but he has never been convicted of any crime related to the cases. They are frustrated by the systemic racism and police negligence that plagued the investigation and the lack of progress in finding Colleen's body.
What are the ongoing efforts to find justice for the victims?
A new task force was formed in 1996 to reinvestigate the murders. The task force re-interviewed witnesses and gathered new evidence, but the prosecution declined to pursue charges against James. The families of the victims continue to advocate for justice and closure.
What is the current status of the Bauerville Murders?
The Bauerville Murders remain unsolved. James has never been convicted of any crime related to the cases. The families of the victims continue to seek justice and closure.
Show Notes
When three Aboriginal children go missing in a span of several weeks in the small town of Bowraville, New South Wales, Australia, a community is divided, and a long battle for justice begins.
- If you know anything about the murders in Bowraville, NSW, Australia, in the 1990s, please contact the New South Wales Crime Stoppers at nsw.crimestoppers.com.au.
This episode references the spoken names and images of deceased Aboriginal people. We acknowledge the cultural sensitivities involved in discussing and referencing deceased individuals from Indigenous communities. Our intention is to shed light on these cases with great care and respect, and to advocate for these victims and their families in the hopes that long-awaited answers and justice can finally be served.
Source materials for this episode cannot be listed here due to character limitations. For a full list of sources, please visit: crimejunkiepodcast.com/infamous-the-bowraville-murders/
Did you know you can listen to this episode ad-free? Join the Fan Club! Visit crimejunkie.app/library/ to view the current membership options and policies.
Don’t miss out on all things Crime Junkie!
- Instagram: @crimejunkiepodcast | @audiochuck
- Twitter: @CrimeJunkiePod | @audiochuck
- TikTok: @crimejunkiepodcast
- Facebook: /CrimeJunkiePodcast | /audiochuckllc
Crime Junkie is hosted by Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat.
- Instagram: @ashleyflowers | @britprawat
- Twitter: @Ash_Flowers | @britprawat
- TikTok: @ashleyflowerscrimejunkie
- Facebook: /AshleyFlowers.AF
Text Ashley at 317-733-7485 to talk all things true crime, get behind the scenes updates, and more!
Table of contents
United States
