The 2025 College Football Playoff first round has ignited a firestorm of criticism over the "5+7" format, as Tulane and James Madison (JMU) were blown out on the national stage. While these programs secured automatic bids as two of the five highest-ranked conference champions, their non-competitive performances have left fans wondering how BYU (11-2) and Utah (10-2) were left sitting at home.

The "5+7" Fallout: Brand Bias vs. Automatic Bids

The inclusion of Tulane and JMU was a mathematical necessity of the current CFP rules, but it resulted in what many are calling a "diluted" playoff product. Tulane, the AAC champion, fell 41–10 to Ole Miss, a game so lopsided that ESPN/TNT commentators Jesse Palmer and Joe Tessitore openly questioned if the matchup would have been more competitive with a team like Notre Dame or BYU. Meanwhile, JMU struggled in a 51–34 loss to Oregon, a score that masks the fact that the Dukes were down 31 points in the first half.

Drake Toll and the Big 12 "Snub"

The most vocal critic of this outcome has been Drake Toll, a prominent Big 12 analyst who has become a fixture on any list of famous Toll names for his fearless defense of the conference. Toll branded the first-round blowouts a "symptom of a broken system," arguing that BYU and Utah were "cheated" by a format that prioritizes mid-major champions over elite Power Four depth. Toll’s analysis highlights a "brand bias" where the committee penalizes 11-win Big 12 teams for "cannibalization" while allowing lower-tier champions to take up valuable real estate in the bracket.

A Playoff Product in Crisis

The "bad games" produced by Tulane and JMU have handed ammunition to those who want to scrap automatic bids for the Group of Five. Critics argue that while the "underdog story" is good for mid-December headlines, it fails the "eye test" on the field. For BYU and Utah fans, watching Tulane and JMU struggle served as a painful reminder that the current system values a trophy in a weaker conference more than a 10-win season in the gauntlet of the Big 12.

Everydayer Club  
If you never miss an episode, it’s time to make it official. Join the Locked On Everydayer Club and get ad-free audio, access to our members-only Discord, and more — all built for our most loyal fans. 

Click here to learn more and join your team’s community: https://lockedonpodcasts.com/everydayerclub  

Support Us By Supporting Our Sponsors!
 

Gametime
Today's episode is brought to you by Gametime. Download the Gametime app, create an account, and use code LOCKEDONCOLLEGE for $20 off your first purchase. Terms and conditions apply.

FanDuel
Today's episode is brought to you by FanDuel. Football season is around the corner, visit the FanDuel App today and start planning your futures bets now.

FANDUEL DISCLAIMER: 21+ in select states. First online real money wager only. Bonus issued as nonwithdrawable free bets that expires in 14 days. Restrictions apply. See terms at sportsbook.fanduel.com. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit FanDuel.com/RG (CO, IA, MD, MI, NJ, PA, IL, VA, WV), 1-800-NEXT-STEP or text NEXTSTEP to 53342 (AZ), 1-888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org/chat (CT), 1-800-9-WITH-IT (IN), 1-800-522-4700 (WY, KS) or visit ksgamblinghelp.com (KS), 1-877-770-STOP (LA), 1-877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY), TN REDLINE 1-800-889-9789 (TN)

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.